Respected columnist Dan Rafel's updated p4p list

Haye should be near the top 10.

He's achieved more than Hatton, De La Hoya, Winky and Mosley recently.

 

David Haye not on there is a disgrace

Winky-Wright and Mosley so high?

De La Hoya??????????

 

Winky Wright is one of my favorite fighters...but what exactly has he done in the past 3 years to earn that high acclaim?

 

I agree Haye should be on there.
But in terms of total accomplishments, he is slightly lacking.

Haye is a top 15 guy for me.

DLH in the top 15 is a DISGRACE!

 

Awful list.

Hopkins too high, as usual. The last time Bernard fought a young opponent, he dropped a pair of decisions.

Pavlik way, way too high. I like Kelly, but he'd get his clocked cleaned by Kessler. Spinks looked horrible against Taylor and previously was awarded a close/bad decision against Karmazin. Why is he still ranked?

Winky is too high. Mosley is too high. Jesus, does he acknowledge that there are fighters outside the United States?

De La Hoya isn't even close to a PfP fighter at this point.

Where is David Haye? Chad Dawson? Mijares? And Wladimir has been dominant, so at least he should be in the top 20.

Horrible, biased list.

 

Should not be on it/is too high.
De La Hoya way too high.
Hatton could be a couple of places lower
Shane is not top 10
Winky far far too high, he has done nothing to warrent this place.
Hopkins too high.
Pavlik a place or two lower.
Taylor fights at 168 now so he is not top 20.
Chris John above Guzman :scaredas:
But the big one Antonio Margarito I mean what the **** is that.


Should be on it/not high enough.
Mikkel Kessler slots in at 15ish
Guzman should be higher.
Cristian Mjiares should be in about 11/12
Juan Diaz is still top 20.
No Chad Dawson?????
David Haye?????

 

a

A close hard fought loss to Hopkins, draw to Taylor and a very blah win against Ike Quartey (who IMHO didn't even want to be there) aren't enough to earn top 10 P4P status right now.

I feel like it's almost the "Lifetime Achievement Award"

 

He might cease to be a "respected columnist" if this is the trash he comes up with

 

I have

1. Floyd
2. Manny
3. JMM
4. B-Hop
5. JC
6. Cotto
7. Izzy
8. Pavlik
9. Rafa
10. Winky
11. Shane
12. Hatton
13. Haye
14. Taylor
15. Montiel

 

Mosley just lost a 7-5 fight with a top 10 pfp guy in Cotto, why wouldnt Mosley be top 15?

 

11 though? You really think Mosley is one of the 11 best fighters on the planet right now?

Late teens if I'm feeling generous

 

1-Floyd
2-Manny
3-JMM
4-Joe Calz
5-Bernard Hopkins
6-Miguel Cotto
7-Izzy Vazquez
8-Rafa
9-Kelly Pavlik
10- Bad Chad Dawson
11-Mijares
12- Winky
13- Shane Mosley
14-Joan Guzman
15- Wlad

Then again I'm basing off recent accomplishments.

 

Top 10 not bad,B-hop is a bit high but that will be sorted soon.
Where the **** is Mijares - not even top 20
Kessler is top 20 also