Honestly, I don't doubt Black (who is allblack if I am correct) knows more about In-Jin Chi than all of us. But boxers are known to "retire" and then comeback. It hasn't been a whole year since his last fight. At the end of the year, if he doesn't have a fight scheduled, I will remove him from my rankings.
Is there some reason you won't apply for the Committee? You obviously have a great deal of knowledge about the small ones, and while everyone will value your opinion as a poster, you might as well have an official vote. You don't have to mess with HWs or the other larger classes, if that doesn't interest you.
Nothing on boxrec yet. Not why I didnt include him tho. Being 1-5 in his last 6 with 2 KO losses.....and no wins since 2004 will bump ya out of the top teir. Still one of my all time favorites tho.
i know little about the big boys outside the topcontenders as i am a fan foremost of the lighter divisions and now that i have seen your product, i'm happy with what you came up with and will nominate myself next month. i will be glad to help you out with your rankings. good job you guys. this is a very good unbiased ranking system:good
Everything looks really good. I still don't see why Ivan Calderon is so high... Although he has beaten some good fighters, he hasn't done it very convincingly. His D is excellent but he'll get caught soon. I'd take Solis over him in their division.
Very good rankings, well done boys... Very few arguments from me, if any really. :good (And well done Lampley too, wasn't quite sure how it was gonna turn out, but it's looking damn good... thanks a lot to you).
:good There's also plenty of time (and now a really good reason) to open a thread about the smaller guys and have a bit of a public chat about it all. Nice job Lampley.
very solid list, and very balanced out. a few things i find unusual though, such as abraham higher than taylor? seems unusual from my perspective considering abraham has fought no one of note. mijares domination of arce was a very good performance (the guy is the future king of the division), but imo not enough to put him no.1 at super fly.
Wow, excellent lists. I wasn't sure if it would turn out as well as it did, but I guess with people having their own certain biases, these are washed out to an extent as the other lists balance it. Very awesome. Congratulations to the committee and a big thanks to Lampley, because this obviously takes some time to do.
It might have been solid were it not for Hopkins be ing at 4. Calzaghe may be a little high now as well.