Rewatched Floyd vs Maidana.

maidana won it was a robbery not as bad as the castilo fight but still a robbery could of been a draw thoe....

 

Rescored, watched in slow motion. It's 114-114.
Maidana took 1, 3, 4, 5, 8, 12.

Before people say it was definitely a Mayweather win, those poeple should try and agree over what rounds he actually won, because I see that they cannot, so a Maidana victory 115-113 is actually very plausible.

Mayweather 44-1-1

 

Yea mayweather was standing his ground and controlling the action and maidana with body shots.
mayweather 7 rounds to 5 at worst 8-4 at best.

 

First watch i had it a draw.

Second time i had Maidana by fifth round KO.

 

Sounds about right to me.

Rounds 3 and 4 were very close. I gave round 3 to FLoyd for his effective punching and round 4 I gave to Maidana because FLoyd slowed down that round from the headbutt he received, his punch output decreased that round as he kept pawing at his eye when blood was trickling into it.

Between rounds 6-12 I only gave Maidana the 8th round and even that was relatively close- the only effective punches Maidana had that round was a low blow with his left hook that was followed by a left hook upstairs that landed cleanly.

Personally I had the fight at 8-4 but you can say it was a 7-5 or 9-3 fight and I wouldn't have an issue with it. I can't see how this fight was a draw, Maidana surely didn't win 6 rounds in that fight.

The only legal shots he landed throughout the night were clean body shots when FLoyd was pressed up on the ropes. Almost all of Maidana's attack upstairs was illegal, with at least 20 shots thrown to the back of FLoyd's head in the nape region. Those are illegal shots and Marcos should've been deducted accordingly.

I don't want to see a rematch because I have a strong feeling FLoyd will fight more similar to how he fought in the last 6 rounds of their first fight- utilize the center of the ring, use his lateral movement to side step Marcos anytime FLoyd is close to being pinned on the ropes, and avoid getting into long exchanges in the pocket with him.

I'd imagine a rematch would be around a 9-3 or 10-2 win. Marcos was able to get a way with a lot of borderline illegal shots, was allowed to rough up FLoyd and didn't receive any point deductions. I seriously doubt a rematch would have a similar outcome compared to their first fight.

 

draw, 7-5, or 8-4 for Mayweather. I dont see Maidana winning 7 rounds. 1,5,8 are the only clear ones for Maidana.

 

Close fight? Cant decide? Then score it like this:

Who was the better boxer?
Which boxer would have won if the fight went another 5 rounds?
Who do you think would win a rematch?

Mayweather
Mayweather
Mayweather

As it happened, I gave Maidana 4 round MAX! Maybe 3.

I've watched it 3 times now

 

114-114. There were times Floyd would gain huge, early leads in a round outlanding Maidana 6-7 punches landed then Maidana would wake up and regain the lead, and back and forth and so forth. I can understand this fight being won by either fighter by one point, I won't argue with that, but IMO I don't think Floyd did enough to win.

 

Maidana won by vicious knockout in the 12th after a complete shut out. Mayweather didn't land 1 clean jab the whole fight.

Duck weather, void is void, he lost to Castillio who was a journeyman, he was knocked down by Zab Judah, chicken weather.

Lol come on guys don't try and have a sensible discussion. People on here can't score fights they are just kids. I gave Maidana 5 at a push but definitely a clear 4 rounds.

 

I scored it for Mayweather, but wasn't impressed AT ALL! He looked like absolute ****, comparable, to how I've seen him look.

This is the first time ever, I'm even entertaining the thought of Khan or Pac beating him. He looked that bad.