Richie Woodhall, Clinton Woods, Robin Reid or Scott Harrison?

Scott Harrison wasn't a world champion, and is also a knobhead.

That secures his place at the bottom of the list, against 3 very good 168/175lb'ers.

 

Robin Reid was definitely the most skilled of the bunch, Woodall or Woods probably had the best career. Harrison was a good fighter but a wasted talent.

 

Woods achievments are OK but he was gifted a decision against Johnson which I thought was disgraceful. His talent lets him down.

Ried was semi decent talent and semi decent achievment


Woodhall was a good talent and a little bit of an underachiever

I have Harrison in top spot as the most talented by far and he still was a 2 times FW champion who would have done so much more had he stayed on the rails. His earlier career performances were far more convincing and his talent was far clearer at the top level.

 

in terms of talent - achievement ratio it has to be woods. hardworking but averagely talented boxer who won a world title and defended successfully.

reid was probably the most skilled of the 4.

 

I dont think calzaghe desperatley wanted it!