Ricky Hatton most dominant champ @140...

It didn't read "with the initials RH" earlier, Sherlock.

 

I truly think Hatton is a Top10 Junior Welterweight of all time.

1. Julio Cesar Chavez
2. Kostya Tszyu
3. Aaron Pryor

4. Antonio Cervantes
5. Nicolino Locche
6. Barney Ross

7. Jack Kid Berg
8. Ricky Hatton
9. Eddie Perkins
10. Tony Canzoneri

11. Wilfredo Benitez
12. Duilio Loi

 

Your argument maes no sense, just because you beat a fighter, does not make you as great as he is....example, No one thinks Buster Douglas achieved more than Tyson or is as great or dominant.....he beat him....Forrest is not as Great as Mosley....and Vargas like it or not beat Winky but hes not as great as Winky.......a Rrime Chavez would have walked through Kostya...not the old version he fought....

 

Hatton is a hair above being an all time BUM!

 

You know me and you have this debate

 

It was a joke uising Bigtime9's logic and criteria...or lack of.

 

You know what I think, my man: Kostya Tszyu beat more contenders in a better era for the 140 division. Pryor might have looked better -toe to toe- because he fought weaker opposition.

Here are some rankings to check out: http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.php/The_Ring_Magazine%27s_Annual_Ratings


But it's close, more or less like the Ali-Louis discussion at Heavyweight or the Moore-Charles at Lightheavyweight.

 

My time machine's on the blink, Watson

 

you dont think 37 is old for that weight class? then fighters are retiring way too early.

 

:good