if bowe had been more diciplined and had a decent head on his shoulders then i think he would have went down as one of the best heavyweights ever. if you watch his first fight with holyfield, he has all the tools and abilities with the skill set to give anyone a handfull of a time. had of he of fought lewis when there were talking and negotiating the fight, i think bowe would of certainly beat lewis, (this is the lewis just before being knocked out by mccall), however the lewis that had steward in his corner would prove to be a tougher match up. i personally still think bowe would prevail because he was better in every department other than the jab (only because he relied on it less than lewis because he was a fantastic in-fighter, HOWEVER bowes jab was faster, just watch the holyfield fight.) and out-fighting skills (only just and not enough for lewis to out box bowe at all). bowe had the better chin, infighting ability, was tougher, threw combinations, good body puncher, faster, every punch he threw was effective, stamina (threw 711 punches against holyfield, and although lewis through alot against holy, he threw over 300 jabs), and power ( i have a magazine where holyfield rates the fighters who had better power, speed etc and he says bowe hit him hardest over any fighter, while he says lewis is the smartest) sorry if its long guys, just letting you know my opinion of bowe and would like to hear yours btw heres the link if anyone hasnt seen the fight: [ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPejZhE6cq0[/ame]
Agree. I believe, as do others, that Bowe is one of the best heavyweghts ever. Certainly a nightmare H2H for most heavies. Most people wouldn't include him in their top 10, however I agree with a recent post that there was a relatively short stretch of time when Bowe could have beaten any fighter from any era, he was that good.
yeah H2H he would be a beast, it is respectable to not include in a top 10 heavies list as his prime was so short, which could of been much longer if for not unfortunate circumstances, however in his prime he was as eddie futch said one of the most talented heavies ever
There have been a lot of great champions who had the same tools, who fulfilled their potentials, who stayed disciplined, who met more rivals of their own era and Bowe has to be ranked behind them. If you list all the best heavyweights of Bowe's era it is a longer list that the ones he actually fought. Lewis, Moorer, Ruddock, Morrison, Briggs, Foreman, Tua, Tucker, Bentt, Tyson, Mercer, Bruno, Rahman, McCall, Grant. Truth is for all his talent those fights were not made and would have all been tougher on him than the fights he had. Bowe was easy hit. Bowe had talent but he also had a lot going for him. He was matched well on the way up, he passed all the early tests then got a new champion who was facing his first live young super heavyweight challenger who was many pounds lighter, many inches shorter To challenge. Bowe still could have messed that up, he did not. He won a great fight and the champion he beat went on to become a great fighter so history shows that helped Bowe's resume, however, as a career that win was it. The end of his progression. His one big win. against a fighter regarded as the best. No other fight Bowe had after that was to decide who was the best Heavyweight in the world after that first Holyfeild fight. Bowe would lose to the same guy who produced his best win. Then, although he also beat him back that was after Holyfeild had lost some lustre. Both were outshone by other champions he did not meet. So what could have been? Bowe v Lewis would have been essential. That fight should have happened instead of Bowe vs. Ferguson and Dokes. Two worthless fights. Bowe vs Holyfeild 2 was not that relevant with Lewis around. Bowe vs Ruddock, Mercer, Foreman, Moorer, McCall, Bruno would have been better than Bowe vs Hide and buster mathis jnr. Holyfeild 3rd time around was a cross roads fight of ex champions, yesterday men in actual terms at that point.
One of the biggest career mistakes in boxing was made by Bowe when he did not fight Lewis right after beating Holyfield. Bowe at the time was at his peak and Lewis who was a late bloomer in terms of peaking was still devloping. Up intill 96 Bowe would have won that fight.
good post. yes those fights would of been tough for him and the lewis fight should of happened as well as many others, but this is where his weaknesses came in, poor matchmaking as you stated, his love of food and weight draining habbits, and he is also one of those individuals that get brain damaged easily, which is unfortinate as he wasnt in that many tough fights to be damaged at 29 from the 2nd golota fight. and you brought up a excellent point which is one of bowes few weaknesses, and that is he isnt to hard to hit, but i wouldnt say easy. the reason he got hit was because he loved to in-fight and he was brilliant at it, but being a big guy there is a lot of areas to hit. after his 2 defences that i believe is where he started going down hill. i disagree with you however were you say the were many other champions how had potential like bowe, there are very few heavies that have the same physical abilities as bowe btw has anyone seen bowes fight against ferguson - second defence, i have not seen it and futch clainms it to be his best performance?
i agree, lewis might of won when they were both old as you have stated, but prime against prime and if they fought when they should have, bowe would have won.
I think all champions had the potential to be champions, they might not have been the same shape and size as Bowe but there were a lot who could jab better like Louis, ali, Holmes and Liston. Each had a better work rate and were more consistent in fights contesting who was the best of their era's. apart from Ali they were also as great inside. Thats three heavyweights with the same skillset who were better. If you take a look at the best, most dominant heavyweights within the division’s history they have been under 225lb anyway so I would ask what kind of asset is being over 230lb in a historical, dominant ATG sense? Larry Holmes had the same tools. A great outside fighter who could brawl inside. Larry fought more heavyweights from his own era too. Much better work rate. So much more proven than Bowe. Of those nearer Bowes size over 228lb there are title holders who had the same kind of skillset and (funny enough) consistency as bowe himself. In fact history shows us that until the Klit boys came along 228lb plus equals inconsistency. Buster Douglas was a massive under achiever but ..so far as what he could do ... at least on Busters best night he was at least as good as Riddick. Tim witherspoon could do most of the stuff Bowe was good at, he used the kenny nortan crab stance but he did jab well and was a demon inside. Hit at least as hard. Greg Page was a big man too. A slower ali clone only he could hit a lot harder than ali and (when in the mood) like Bowe, could brawl better than muhammad Ali. Bowe looked great but with only one fight of his being worthy of deciding "the best heavyweight in the world" he must be measured against those who contested more times for that honour and I don’t just mean title defences. I mean show downs that the decide the best out there.
i am not saying that he is a proven champion and he doesnt deserve to be because he is a waste of talent, and i am not saying he could be as good as the greats of holmes, ali, louis etc, but he had the all round ability to (if he was consistant and fought the top fighters) be listed among them, i think holmes and ali are 2 boxers who could beat bowe regardless of how great he could have been because they were better on the outside and wouldnt brawl. riddick was deffenetly better then douglas on his night, he only looked good because of how bad tyson looked. i disagree about him and larry having the same abilities, yes larry would beat him, but was not a havey puncher like bowe and was not as good a brawler as bowe. futch who trained norton, holmes and frazer said that bowe had the potential to the be the best heavyweight he ever had. and about the work rate i was saying how his work rate was excellent for a big man, 711 punches is very good for a 235lb 6ft5 guy.
I believe he was an overachiever. He was lucky to sniff a title, took an easy as hell route to Holy, fought an inconsistent, small champ, defended against nohopers and was destroyed by a perennial b-rater. Porous defense and a general lack of durability equalled a short career.
You're right saying in saying that Bowe was due to face Lewis during late 1994 for the WBC title that Bowe previously put in a dustbin. After Lewis beat Ruddock in a WBC elimination bout in Oct, 1992, he was next for a shot at Bowe, who won the WBC/WBA/IBF belts in, Nov, from Holyfield. Early 1993. Bowe drops the WBC belt rather than face Lewis. Lewis is awarded the title and defends against Tucker. Nov, 1993. Holyfield beats Bowe in their rematch. Lewis shows some interest in fighting Holyfield, which would bring back a one undisputed champion. April, 1994. Holyfield loses to Michael Moorer. Late 1994. Lewis and Bowe are penciled for a showdown for Lewis' WBC belt.
June 18th, 1994. Yesterday promoters for World Boxing Council heavyweight champion Lennox Lewis and former champion Riddick Bowe announced the two would finally meet sometime in late fall. That development occurred after negotiations by both fighters to land a bout with World Boxing Association and International Boxing Federation champion Michael Moorer collapsed amid demands for options and rematch clauses. Although Bowe's manager, Rock Newman, said Lewis would be guaranteed $18 million and Bowe $13 million, no money is yet guaranteed, even by TVKO, the pay-per-view arm of Time Warner that will distribute the fight.
NEW YORK -- Riddick Bowe is set to fight for the WBC heavyweight title belt he threw into a trash can 18 months ago. The former undisputed heavyweight champion has signed to fight WBC champion Lennox Lewis in November or December. "A deal has been signed by all of us, and it is an iron-clad deal," Rock Newman, Bowe's manager, said during a conference call Friday from London. Newman said Lewis is guaranteed $18 million and Bowe is guaranteed $13 million. "We're looking forward to Lewis being recognized as the best heavyweight out there," said Lewis' manager, Frank Maloney, who attended a news conference in London with promoter Panos Eliades. Newman said he thought the winner of the match would be recognized as the real heavyweight champion, and not Michael Moorer, who won the IBF and WBA titles from Evander Holyfield on April 22. The fight is scheduled to be held in the United States between the first week in November and the first week in December. It will be shown on pay-per-view. Bowe won the undisputed championship by outpointing Holyfield on Nov. 13, 1992. A month later, he threw the WBC belt into a trash can to protest a mandated title defense against Lewis.