Rigondeux, Donaire, Broner, Gamboa?

Broner shouldn't even be on that list..

knocking out Litzau? Really?

 

any body who rates these guys over Rigondeaux cant see his true talent.

that boy moves like a ****in cat and sharp as hell. i SERIOUSLY see any one beating him.

hes right behind floyd and Ward talentwise IMO. his performance against Kennedy was amazing to watch.

Rigos the Troof!!

 

agreed :good

 

Clearly talented, but not yet proven against the same caliber as Gamboa and Donaire. Sorry.


Whereas Broner is neither as proven nor (IMO) as talented.

 

Excellent reply, although again Gamboa and Donaire could be flipped on either side.

 

Skill wise


Rigondeaux



































The rest

 

ok heres mine "talentwise"

Rigo
Broner
Donair
Gamboa

heres the most proven

Gamboa
Donaire
Broner
Rigondeaux

 

Gamboa and Donaire both depend more on athletiscism than skill

Rigo is a perfect balance of both athleticism and skill


Rigo is a monster and would be P4P king already if he had a good fanbase


Broner is overrated

 

Nice. :good


Why Broner more proven than Rigo, though?


Top three wins as pros:

Shitzau/V-Mart/Prince Eloy (Ponce was a highway robbery, doesn't count)

vs.

Ramos/Cordoba/Casey or Kennedy, take your pick


I say GR wins out, myself.

 

idk, its kind of hard to rate someone that highly with so little fights. but i guess his competition has been pretty solid.

a win over escobedo should be good for Broners resume tho. much better fight then that guy from the UK that was about to happen.

 

Oh no doubt. :yep Gary Sykes would've been stepping back all the way to John Revish level.

WAR CHENTE!

 

Rigo looks to be the biggest thing since Roberto Duran avenged his loss to Esteban De Jesus but I am sure Gamboa is gonna get there first. I don't know exactly what's going on in Gamboa's side but they are about to knock on someone's door and that someone is gonna be trashed. Broner I can't talk about and Donaire seems to be forgotten.

 

:deal

 

At the moment:

Donaire
Gamboa
Rigondeaux
Broner (but I think he'll probably go the furthest out of the 4)

 

He is but I ranked him based on accomplishments and because of that Donaire is higher. Without a doubt Rigo is a top 10 P4P talent just not enough wins under his belt as of yet.