Ring Magazine fighter of the decades

Calzaghe.....

 

I'd put Barrera at Featherweight, and Jones Jr instead of Tarver

 

Shows how weak the 200lb division is when the best of the decade had what one defence of his title?

 

I would actually give it Johnny Nelson he had what 15-20 defences ok not many big names but I would have him ahead of Haye.

 

Haye is their choice at Cruiser? No sir.

 

Cheers for this Rob.

Floyd at LW? He had like what, four fights at that weight? Two against Castillo with one being a close (correct imo) decision? Floyd's best weight was SFW in my opinion, but you can look past Pac at that weight.

I suppose the question then is who should be #1 at LW. Only really Castillo and Corrales spring to mind. So I suppose, H2H, Floyd is above them.

 

I'm not sure about Mayweather Jr at LW but, that said, he did beat Castillo twice who, apart from Coralles, is the only real alternative.

 

I'm at a loss to think of anyone else.

Juan Carlos Gomez moved up very early in the decade, so he's out. Then it comes down to guys like Mormeck, Bell, Braithwaite or Guilermo Jones.

Anyone else?

Johnny Nelson?!?

 

Lights Out

 

Roy Jones Jnr should be in their.

 

He's got my vote.:good

 

Some of the selections are bizarre.

Seems like an attempt to get everybody in that they want.

 

you do realise that a decade is 10 years don't you and he hasn't beaten a relevent fighter since his 2003 win over Tarver?