Ring Magazine Pound 4 Poung list its a joke!!

:nono He actually dropped from 'beating' Paulie.

[url]http://ringtalk.com/kps-holiday-boxing-notes[/url]

 

What about either Takashi at 130?

 

I'd put Crawford up a bit, kovalev up to 6

 

holy **** that is actually a horrible list

 

cgood to see some boxers on there such as Gonzalez and Wlad but others like Bradley and Marquez dont belong

 

:good:yep

 

my bad. I guess i wanted to remember it differently.

 

Either of them at 9 or 10 would be "acceptable" would personally go with Yamanaka though.

 

After going back through all of both Miura and Yamanaka's recent fights last week I'd have Miura highest of the 3 right now. Yamanaka's a beast too. In the end I defer to your opinion on Japanese fighters. (Except when it comes to KO Dynamite vs. Jom). :bbb

 

P4P, Kazuto Ioka > Gennady Golovkin.

The three best wins between them all belong to Ioka.

He has beaten three fighters who held title belts at the time, compared to Golovkin's zero.

The supporting wins Golovkin has beyond Geale, Murray, and Macklin aren't enough to elevate the difference between those three moderate top victories and Ioka's excellent top victories over Oleydong (consensus #1), Yaegashi, and Reveco. This would be a further landslide if Ioka had been given the decision that he deserved over Amnat Ruenroeng, who is quite a good fighter and highly ranked titlist himself.

However, Ioka falls short of making my list as well.

...and that is why you are crazy if you have had Golovkin on your P4P list for more than a year and if you have him on your list now anywhere above squeezing him into 9th or 10th.

 

Assume Froch and Marquez are taken out for inactivity- would you have Monster Inoue in then?

I really don't think there is that much to split him and Rigondeaux anymore. Rigo's been stuck in neutral trying to get big fights since the Donaire fight (and didn't look great his last fight), in that time Inoue has beat Taguchi, Hernandez and Navarez.