***Ring Magazine Pound For Pound Rankings***

That list is pretty much as mine, though Hopkins and Cotto would be reversed, as would Marquez and Pavlik.

 

Arum is doing well... 3 fighters in the top 10 and the #1 P4P fighter...

Golden boy has 3 fighters

 

I would like to see Calderon having some unification fights, and to get rid of the WBO trinket

Top class operators should have more than just a WBO belt.

 

toprank has 4 fighters not 3...

pavlik, cotto, pac, calderon

 

thanks for that correction ! doin better than i thought!

 

:good

 

Boxing rec has Joe C #1 for what thats worth..

But here is my P4P list:

1. Pac
2. Joe C
3. Cotto
4. Vazquez
5. JMM
6. Pavlik
7. R. Marquez
8. Mijares
9. Hatton
10. Mosely

 

****ing cavemen must be in charge of boxrec's list...

 

For good measure, BoxRec's top 10 p4p list:

1 Joe Calzaghe
2 Kelly Pavlik
3 Bernard Hopkins
4 Manny Pacquiao
5 Juan Manuel Marquez
6 Winky Wright
7 Wladimir Klitschko
8 Israel Vasquez
9 Chris John
10 Cristian Mijares

Cotto in 16th, Marquez 17th, no Calderon in the top 25.

 

Boxrec P4P rankings are pretty lame......

Though they generally have the best guys at the top of their respective divisions.

 

I'd really like to know how there points system works (or rather doesn't work).

 

Mine looks like this - let battle commence (I assume consensus on the top two so havent put anything in there)

1] Manny Pac
2] Joe Calzaghe
3] Israel Vazquez
I had Raf Marquez as my number 5 behind Juan Manuel Marquez who was number 4 before Vazquez beat Raf. As a result Vazquez jumps to number 3 as linear super bantam champ and everyone getting bumped one after Floyd's retirement.
4] Miguel Cotto
Still undefeated and wins over Mosley, Judah, Urkal and Quintana at welter. Two weight world champ but it’s the '0' on the record and his CV which puts him this high up. A win over Marg could challenge Vaz for the #3 spot.
5] Juan Manuel Marquez
Slim loss to Pacquiao drops him to six. Coming towards end of career though so only really likely to fall down my list from now on.
6] Kelly Pavlik
Linear middleweight champion, two impressive performances over Jermaine Taylor (previous linear champ) as well as a good win over Miranda. Best of a mediocre middleweight division but undefeated linear champion so deserves to be in top ten.
7] Rafael Marquez
Two defeates to Israel Vazquez on the bounce drops him to 7
8] Christian Mijares
WBC and WBA superlyweight champ. Looked unbeatable since about 2006.
9] Ricky Hatton
I had Ricky at number 6 before defeat to Mayweather. Manner of loss and performance of others have made him drop 3 places. A win over any decent light-welter would be enough for him to leap frog both Raf Marquez and Mijares.
10] Ivan Calderon
Second defence of his light-flyweight title ending in a wide points decision is enough to sneak him into top ten at expense of B-Hop.

 

boxrec has a lame list very flawed system. Pac is even no.1 at the lightweight rankingsatsch

 

I know, i've searched the site to see if i could find out how thier rankings work but i couldnt find it...