Berto, Bute and Mosley shouldn't even be options for this poll. Hopkins, Ward, Froch, and Khan are decent choices for the #10 position.
Yes, he should. It's a list of the top 10 fighters from 17 weight divisions with thousands of competitors in each from all over the world. If you get blown away in 2 rounds you shouldn't be in there, at least until you redeem yourself. They'll probably stick an American in there, probably Ward.
Ward, Pascal, Hopkins, Bute all have a case for top 15. Mosley, Khan and Berto do not. Especially Berto.
In my view, losing to someone ranked several places above you on the P4P ranking shouldn't necessitate an automatic ejection from the P4P rankings. If you're #10 P4P, you're SUPPOSED to lose to the #4 P4P if you're both in the same weight range. He should stay where he's at.
It'll probably be Ward. Also, like him or not, Froch's achievements should at least get him a mention.
Thank you. I was thinking the same thing. Adamek should be up there. He's not even in Dan Rafael's ESPN top 20, which is so fraudulent.
TheRing did a 100 last month on their website so presumably someone next in time might get bumped up. Here's the top 20: http://ringtv.craveonline.com/blog/124969-ring-100-ranking-the-best-fighters-in-the-world