Ring Magazine's #1/Champion's square off: 1939 v 1989

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by McGrain, Feb 7, 2010.


  1. PowerPuncher

    PowerPuncher Loyal Member Full Member

    42,723
    279
    Jul 22, 2004
    1. I've looked its not that good

    2, no ridng a shot, Ive never used that term

    3. The obvious difference is Conn cant sit in the pocket and counter, where Toney can

    4. Im exagerating, but hes far far faster of hand and foot, MASSiVE ADVANTAGE

    5. When have you ever seen anyone control distance and timing better than Jones in all of his prime fights? You havent he always dominates ring generalship

    6. Its good we know agree Jones is 10times better on everything other than perhaps chin :yep

    7. Short punches mean little if your feet are moving at 1mph

    8. You make a goodpoint, the beatings Conn took shows his defense wasnt particularly good :yep

    9. Conn didnt fight better fighters and has more bums on his record. Bottom line Conn only fought 1 black fighter and got KTFO by him :yep

    10. Hopkins and Toney both prime :yep both light years ahead of Conns opposition :yep

    11. Yea I made it up despite it being on boxrec. Go on boxrec and look it up LAZY

    12. Jones many opponents of 190-200lb who drained to make LHW were probably the same size

    13. Maybe 1 or 2 of Jones opponents had jobs to maintain themselves, Conn fought way more part timers than Jones. Bottom line though 30 of Jones opponents were top 10 ranked

    14. No they didnt, Jones and his contemparies competed in a better era, the best MW era of all time

    15. Well yourwrong both Hops and Toney keep their zeros if they face Conns opposition
     
  2. burt bienstock

    burt bienstock Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    18,285
    411
    Jan 22, 2010
    Billy Conn at his peak was one of the very top lightheavies that ever lived...As a middle weight Conn licked some great fighters, such as Fred Apostoli, Solly Krieger, Young Corbett, Tough Oscar Rankins, prime Fritzie Zivic,etc.Some of these guys had well over 100 bouts... As a lightheavy,Billy Conn beat tremendous fighters of that tough time, as Melio Bettina, Gus Lesnevich,Bob Pastor, Lee Savold, Gunnar Barlund,etc.Some of them weremuch heavier fhan Conn. And then of course, his best fight against arguably the greatest heavyweight that ever lived,a prime Joe Louis,in 1941.... Billy at about 169 lbs , as we all know almost dethroned the Brown Bomber, even outweighed by 30 lbs....Louis ,aside from one ko suffered by Conn when he was 17 years old, was the only one to ever ko billy conn....No shame there....Roy Jones as a lightheavyweight, would not have beaten some of Conn's victims, such as the tough punching Lesnevich, Southpaw Melio Bettina, yes,Bob Pastor, and let alone lasted 13 rounds with the great power punching Brown Bomber.....Not with his being ko,d by several decent ,but not great lightheavies....Yes Conn, with his speed and durability,in many, many 15 round bouts whips Roy Jones...Conn too seasoned.....
     
  3. anarci

    anarci Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    24,237
    64
    Jul 21, 2009
    Im assuming every one agrees with this ^^^^
     
  4. janitor

    janitor VIP Member

    71,999
    28,009
    Feb 15, 2006
    Lets look at what that actualy means.

    By his 20th birthday Conn had been in the ring with six world champions:

    Zivic, Risko, Dundee, Yaroz, Young Corbett III, Yaroz again

    By his 21st birthday Conn ahd been in the ring with eleven world champions having fought in the past year:

    Young Corbett II, Yaroz, Cobett again, Kreiger, Yaroz again

    By his 22nd birthgday Conn was the lineal light heavyweight champion and had fought seventeen world champions with only three losses. In the last year he had fought:

    Kreiger, Apostoli, Apostoli again, Kreiger again, Betina, Betina again

    His heavyweight run included fights against eight oponents who had been ranked in the top 10 by ring magazine at one time or another with his only two losses coming to Joe Louios.

    When you say that both Hopkins and Toney would have kept their zeros if they face Conns opposition, I don't think you have even bothered toi think it through.
     
  5. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    114,832
    51,933
    Mar 21, 2007
    :lol: Yeah, this is a thread veered badly off track.

    All reasonable picks.


    Yeah, before he was 21 Conn had matched more great fighters than Toney would ever meet in his long and distinguished career, but apparently Toney keeps his 0 if he is messing with them, in spite of his losses to Griffin, Thadzi, Tiberi and his being out-boxed by Sam Peter. Who knew?