Canelo should not be in either. For me the only fighters with really solid credentials on that list are Mayweather, Márquez, Klitschko, Pacquiao, Martinez and Ward - and the latter two need to show something soon.
Alvarez is my favorite boxer of all time. And I barely recently recognized him as the top 154 pounder (with his win over Trout) let alone P4P top-10. FFS atsch