Roy still has excellent hand speed although whether he can sustain decent workrate for 12 rounds to get a points decision is questionable.
The thing is Roy is one of the rare boxers who was so exceptionally good back in the day it's hard not to pick him even in a declined state. Also I think some reporters pick the underdog because it makes them look good if it comes off - anyone could see it was going to be a one sided victory for Joe. Also, what was all that 3lbs over weight baloney -Pure marketing to make the fight seem more competive then it really was?