Rocky Marciano or Jack Johnson who was the greater fighter?

Green as he may have been, Jeannette had still TKO'd Sam Langford previous to fighting Jack Johnson.

 

Ye he did ,he must have had another jaundice attack atsch

 

Yes, a Langford who had had 46 fights.
How inconvenient of you to mention that , along with Great A , who mentioned that Burns weighed exactly the same 168lbs in an earlier defence of his title against Jem Roche whom he bombed out in one round. Wonder if he had jaundice then too?

 

Your posts are provocative which is good ,we dont agree on Johnson ,but that's fine.How you interpret his career is up to you.
I dont think being kod by Choynsky was a disgrace,Johnson was in his 8th fight and Choynsky kod 34 of his 51 victims.
Johnson broke his arm against Jim Johnson.
Ketchel was in good shape for Johnson he weighed 170lbs more than Fitz did in most of his fights.

 

I'd like to be careful, here, that I don't make Moyle doesn't come across as a Langford fan-boy.
It is very clear, in Moyle's book, that Langford took a beatdown from Johnson in a one-sided contest. Moyle does assert that Sam occaisionally landed effective punches and that both were tired at the fights end; but he certainly admits that Langford received far more facial damage and did not land anywhere near as many punches as Johnson; and Moyle never asserts that Johnson was in any immenent danger of being stopped, just that he was shook on a few occaisions, but tied Sam up before it could develope into anything really problematic.

 

Thanks for the info.both Johnson at 185lbs and Langford at 156lbs were short of their respective peaks. Johnson had 38 fights up to then and Langford 50. Prime for prime it would have been one to watch, though I favour Johnson , by dec

 

Johnson was 4-1-2. Choynski was a veteran of more than 60 fights. It was a mismatch in terms of skill. Choynski did not knock Johnson cold. Johnson did not beat the count, but he was not out cold. And the knock out itself was a bit suspicious.

Had the O'Brien-Ketchel contest you mention been six rounds, O'Brien would have been entitled to a clear victory, as he dominated Ketchel through the first eight rounds. Had O'Brien-Johnson been 10 rounds, how then would O'Brien have done? Johnson, clearly out of shape and uninspired, reached him a few times and once had him reeling. Was it only a matter of time? Likely. Don't dismiss O'Brien so easily. He was a tricky boxer.

Since Ketchel and Johnson had agreed to a decision finish, Johnson was not expecting Ketchel to let go like that. And when Ketchel changed the terms of the deal, Johnson ended it right then and there - which it looked like he could have done anytime he decided to.

We have enough film to judge Johnson's abilities. Your argument is not compelling in the least.

 

This is not correct. Johnson had over 20 fights before he meet Choynski! Here is his record going into the fight:
1894 John Lee Galveston, Tx W 16 -Some sources report "KO 15"Undated (circa 1894-95)
Dave Pierson Galveston, Tx W 1895Apr 11

This content is protected

Galveston, Tx L 4 -Some sources report 1899 1896 Cherokee

Kansas City, Ks KO Howard Pollar Galveston, Tx W

1897 Jim Rocks Galveston, Tx KO 4 Sam Smith Galveston, Tx W 10

1898 Reddy Bremer Galveston, Tx KO 3
Jim Cole Galveston, Tx W 4
Henry Smith Galveston, Tx D 15

1899Feb 11 Jim McCormick Galveston, Tx D 7

Mar 17 Jim McCormick Galveston, Tx WF 7May 6

This content is protected

Chicago, Il LT

4Dec 16 Pat Smith Galveston, Tx D 12

1900Mar 7 John Lee Galveston, Tx W

15Mar 20 Willie McNeal Galveston, Tx KO 15

Apr 6 Bob White Galveston, Tx W 15

Apr 12 Charley Brooks Galveston, Tx KO 2

May 1 Jim Scanlan Galveston, Tx KO 7

May 6 Jim McCormick Galveston, Tx KO 2

May 28 Jim McCormick Galveston, Tx KO 7

Jun 12 Horace Miles Galveston, Tx KO 3

Jun 25

This content is protected

Galveston, Tx D 20 -Some sources report 6/28/00

Oct George Lawler Galveston, Tx KO

10Nov Josh Mills Memphis, Tn W 12

Dec 27

This content is protected

Memphis, Tn TK 14 -Some sources report 12/28/00

1901Feb 25 Joe Choynski Galveston, Tx LK 3 -Both fighters were arrested after the fightMar 22 –Johnson and Choynski were released from jail after each posted a $1,000 bondApr


26 Billy Stift Denver, Co D 10

Nov 4

This content is protected

Bakersfield, Ca L 20

Dec 27

This content is protected

Oakland, Ca D 20

True. A past his best supper middle weight out boxed and out jabbed Johnson. Since Johnson claims he wasn't in shape, O'briend coudl have out worked him in the later rounds if was scheduled for 10, or perhaps have been TKO'd. Either way, its very interesting to see what a skilled guy did vs. Johnson. Johnson's vaunted defense and glove blocking didn't help him at all here.

I agree that we have enough flim and news reads to judge him.

 

I dont think that is much better

 

Jeffries said he had never faced a harder puncher.

Jeffries also said, about Johnson, "He's better than I ever was."

 

You won't get any change from Mendoza with that remark !

 

O'Brien is only credited with winning two rounds of the contest. Two rounds went to Johnson and the other two were even.

You just sank your argument!

 

The Galveston Giant. He's a true ATG and he's only dissed by young and ignorant fans who don't appreciate the old school and think modern means "fitter/stronger/harder"!!

 

And a bigot on this forum who has a hate fixation with him.