Rocky Marciano vs. Bernard Hopkins, at a catchweight of 180Ibs., who wins and why?

This ****ing idiot needs to go back to General and stay there...

It was mildly enetertaining at first, but now its irritating.

 

He was 43 years old when calzaghe fought him prime hopkins would scool marciano who's another who fought old fighters and ducked people to stay undefeated

 

I was referring to the overall body of the posts I read from you... Maybe its being here at my in-laws that's making me more irritable, but you are still a ****ing idiot.

 

But to answer the thread, I think Marciano makes the weight without compromising his health, and Hopkins, as crafty and great as he is at surviving and thriving in there, doesn't have enough to hold off Rocky for 15 rounds...

Hopkins will be holding a lot and surviving for a while, but Hopkins simply doesn't have the power to keep Rocky honest. Rocky walks through him and stops him sometime mid to late rounds...

 

Rocky stops him in about 9-10 rounds at the most

 

I'm a dumbass for not thinking Carnera wouldn't get KO'd in the first round?

Your reading comprehension skills are lacking, because I said he may or may not be stopped in the first... Based on his losses to big punchers and one particularly great finisher, the evidence supports my side.

And you have yet again proved my assertion that you are an idiot. By the way, I'm through calling names. It's not normally my style.

I don't understand why I'm an idiot for having an opinion based on facts...

 

What isn't a fact? The film that shows him getting up multiple times from murderous punchers and one particularly great finisher. What never happened? You aren't making much sense... And the one thing you are correct on- the fact that this is all opinion (except for my factual examples)...

 

This is logical. I agree with most of these statements. Even if I don't agree that Tyson is a level above Louis in terms of punching and finishing, that's you opinion and you're entitled to it.

Understand, though- these fighters that are revered and defended based on legacy and longevity got that reputation for a reason. They earned that distinction.

Also, I was taking you to task for stating as a matter of fact (and saying I was an idiot for thinking otherwise) that Carnera would have most definitely not seen the scond round had he and Tyson fought. I stated my opinion based on fights that actually happened and how Carnera reacted to having his ass kicked all over the place. You could also get the sense from my posts that I thought Tyson certainly wouldn't have done any worse that Baer or Louis...

 

Bernie doesn't have the footwork to get a win

 

Shut the **** up...


Telling it like it is...you got opinions like everyone else...only difference is yours are based on less facts.

 

I;m even more convinced B-Hop can beat Marciano by UD. B-hop is way to skill and versatile for the likes of Marciano. I have respect for both and both are Hall of Famers but Skill beats Will almost every time. I'm going with skills here, which is B-Hop!