Marciano is definitely superior in power. You only list Lewis advantages (in your opinion) and not Marciano's. He had a better chin, heart, and better endurance. Those are three very important aspects. He was also mentally tougher.
Marciano also cut easily and had never met anybody who hit as hard as Lewis. I cannot even imagine Mr Marchegiano making a fight of it.
I'm not responding to you because you're a certified idiot, and a troll. You even went so far as to copy a round by round description of a fight you may, or may not have watched, and claim it as your own until l called you on it. At least Mongoose had the guts to watch and debate a disputed round, while all you did was throw snide remarks from the peanut gallery.
The whole notion of Marciano winning against a prime Lewis is lunacy. The only attribute l would give the Rock would be conditioning.
What are you talking about? I never claimed a round by round as my own. You didn't call me out at all whatsoever. I was the one who did the calling out. :yep Here's the thread, so everyone can see what a liar you are. http://www.boxingforum24.com/showthread.php?t=555058
Because I'm not colorblind. Everybody knows you're not supposed to credit physically gifted black athletes for their intangibles. Beside, most were on the official white guy code word list: 1) S****py 2) High motor 3) Gamer 4) Sneaky athletic 5) Gritty 6) Winner 7) High ___ IQ 8) Good fundamentals 9) Plays the game the right way 10) Lunch pail guy 11) Heady and/or cerebral 12) Deceptive speed 13) Gym rat 14) Intangibles 15) Gets the most out of his abilities 16) Has a lot of heart 17) Grinder 18) Out-hustles
No and no. Chin is almost impossible to assess until Marciano is hit cleanly by the likes of Vitali. And heart is also pretty hard to determine. Vitali had Lewis rocked and Lewis hung on, survived, and won the fight. I think all champs have heart otherwise they simply don't get to the top of the mountain.
when you get to world class every fighter scores 10/10 for heart or they wouldnt be where they are but the chin thing ?!?!! How often did Marciano fight a 17st world class heavy, the answer is never. Marciano's management wouldn't let him near Nino Valdez and were made up when 42 year old Archie Moore beat Valdez for a shot at the rock.
No Marciano was never knocked out. Not all champs have heart. Some were just the best in their era and had no competition. Theirs a difference between winning a close fight and fighting through seemingly having your nose splitting off. Marciano had much more heart than Lewis. Their really is no comparison in this.
Marciano was never touched by 230+ lb punchers like Golata, klitscko, Tua, Bruno, ruddock, grant, Briggs, mercer, or Rahman... So saying that he had a better chin because he was never stopped is a moot point..
It's widely recognized Marciano had one of the best chins of all time and Lewis had one of the worst of all time.
Lewis wasn't recognized as having one of the worst of all time. Watch the Holy and Mercer fights, he gets tagged plenty and keeps fighting. That's not the worst of all time.
At least as it pertains to the Lewis fight how was Vitali suppose to show more heart? It looked like left to his own devices the was prepared to risk his eyesight. How much more heart would you like him to have had.