Which win would weigh more? Rodriguez is a highly skilled, somewhat slick, undefeated prime dude who hasn't fought amazing competition. Donaire is a rugged veteran, surefire HOFer with a still lethal left hook, albeit past his best.
Rodriguez prime fight, very skillful and fast. donaire is fast and powerful but reliant on the left hook.
I'll go for Rodriguez. I love Donaire HOF bound as he is and what he's doing at this age and at this weight is remarkable. However, ROdriguez is an unbeaten 26 yr old title holder and Olympic gold medalist. Ring has him 3rd behind Tete, I think they may have those two the wrong way round.