ROY JONES JR - how would his heavyweight career have went 2003-?

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by DINAMITA, Oct 9, 2008.


  1. DINAMITA

    DINAMITA Guest

    MARCH 2003 - Roy Jones Jr beat John Ruiz 116-112,118-110,117-111 to win the WBA heavyweight title. Jones weighed 193lbs, Ruiz 226lbs.

    Had Jones stayed at heavyweight, could he have regularly competed for the best, and been a success amongst the big boys?

    Please give me your initial thoughts on that question, and then your answer on who he could've beaten and who he couldn't have from this list of prominent heavyweights from back in '03:

    WBC Champion - Lennox Lewis
    Size: 6'5", 250lbs
    2003 Form: KO'd Tyson in 8 in '02, only fight of '03 was a win on cuts v Vitali Klitschko when behind on points.

    WBO Champion - Wladimir Klitschko
    Size: 6'6", 240-45lbs
    2003 Form: Stopped in 2 rounds by Corrie Sanders, stopped two journeymen as part of a comeback, then stopped again at start of '04, this time by Lamon Brewster

    IBF Champion - Chris Byrd
    Size: 6', 215lbs
    2003 Form: Beat Holyfield on points in '02, won 1 fight in '03, drew with Golota in '04

    Vitali Klitschko
    Size: 6'7", 250lbs
    2003 Form: Stopped Larry Donald in '02, impressed in a defeat to Lewis in '03, then stopped Kirk Johnson and Corrie Sanders

    James Toney
    Size: 5'10", 220lbs
    2003 Form: Beat Jirov to become cruiserweight champion, added 20lbs and moved up to heavyweight, stopped Holyfield

    Mike Tyson
    Size: 5'10", 230lbs
    2003 Form: Stopped by Lewis in '02, stopped Clifford Etienne in 1 in '03, stopped by Danny Williams in '04

    Evander Holyfield
    Size: 6'2", 220lbs
    2003 Form: Lost to Byrd, Toney, then Donald '02-'04

    Hasim Rahman
    Size: 6'2", 250lbs
    2003 Form: Drew with David Tua, lost to John Ruiz

    Corrie Sanders
    Size: 6'4", 230lbs
    2003 Form: Stopped Wladimir in 2, beaten by Vitali in 8

    Lamon Brewster
    Size: 6'2", 230lbs
    2003 Form: Beating journeymen, then stopped by Wlad in '04

    David Tua
    Size: 5'10", 250lbs
    2003 Form: KO'd Moorer in 1 in '02, drew with Rahman in '03

    Andrew Golota
    Size: 6'4", 240lbs
    2003 Form: Beating journeymen, then drew with Byrd and lost to Ruiz and Brewster in '04


    Contrary to popular belief, I don't believe Roy ever had a "Glass Jaw" until after this fight, he decimated his punch resistance by burning off all that muscle - even though he wasn't aware of it, he had severely weakened his body doing that.
    In the lead-up to the Ruiz fight, Jones had looked as strong as ever toying with bull-strong lhw Clinton Woods and KO'ing Glen Kelly with one punch. In the Ruiz fight, he did get caught once or twice and did not wobble. The guy was pure muscle, a lot tougher than he is given credit for. He took a lot of punches in his 1st fight with Montell Griffin (not a devastating hitter, but 30 KOs in 49 fights shows he could punch), he mixed it with guys as strong as Toney, Hopkins and Richard Hall (26 KOs from 28 wins), and never looked weak before.


    So, how would Jones have done at heavyweight if he had stuck around as WBA heavyweight champion????
     
  2. BobDigi5060

    BobDigi5060 East Side MMA Full Member

    10,898
    2
    Feb 7, 2006
    Along with Holyfield, Tyson and Golota is as far as he would get. He may have beaten a shell shocked Wladimir.
     
  3. Rico Spadafora

    Rico Spadafora Master of Chins Full Member

    45,372
    3,783
    Feb 20, 2008
    Well out of that list he gets knocked out by:

    Lennox

    Both Klitschko's (Wlad has a bad Chin but Roy's is much worse)

    He already has schooled Toney and would have done it again

    Byrd would have TKOed him

    Tua would have put him in a coma

    Brewster would have brutally KOed him

    Golota would lose a fight he was winning

    Sanders would have shattered that Glass Jaw

    Rahman who knows his Chin is Glass also

    Jones probably would have outlasted old Tyson and Holyfield but who knows if either lands flush on that Glass Jaw anything could happen.

    All in all there was a reason Glass Jaw Roy handpicked Ruiz then left the Division. At least James Toney moved up and stayed in the Heavyweight Division not run back to Light Heavyweight and get brutally KOed twice.
     
  4. kickbxn5

    kickbxn5 Active Member Full Member

    521
    5
    Jul 20, 2004
    I think RJJ would have only beaten Byrd and Holyfield and Ruiz. Everyone else would've had him looking like Glenn Johnson did.
     
  5. Mind Reader

    Mind Reader J-U-ICE Full Member

    16,769
    32
    Oct 26, 2006
    You're right, his chin wasn't an issue until he dropped the weight... People act as if it was something he had all along, which if he did Ruiz would have knocked him out in the first round with that pretty big right hand that Jones got hit flush with.

    At that time I would favor Jones over everyone on that list except the Klits, obviously Lennox, Tua, and Sanders...

    I would favor Jones to outpoint Tyson as well.
     
  6. Mind Reader

    Mind Reader J-U-ICE Full Member

    16,769
    32
    Oct 26, 2006
    You're totally wrong yet again....This was before he dropped the weight, no one even thought about a glass jaw. At this point they only saw him take Ruiz's shots and not get effected or hurt in any way, and go on to dominated the man in a fight that some of those guys had already lost to or would in the future.... So in your predictions you can't assume everyone knew he had a glass jaw, doesn't make any sense.
     
  7. COLD-HARD-TRUTH

    COLD-HARD-TRUTH Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,566
    8
    Sep 21, 2008
    I would've picked Jones to beat the smaller heavyweights like Byrd, Toney, Tyson and Holyfield. Think he could've outsmarted and outboxed Tua, Rahman and Brewster. I give him a good chance against Wladimor but the rest of the taller heavyweights Lewis, Sanders and Vitali I think would've been to tall, rangy and hit too hard for Jones to win.
     
  8. Rico Spadafora

    Rico Spadafora Master of Chins Full Member

    45,372
    3,783
    Feb 20, 2008
    good lord nuthugger how did I know you would respond? :patsch

    Jones HANDPICKED Ruiz because of his deplorable KO rate in the 4 years preceding that bout. Jones has a Glass Jaw and has always had a Glass Jaw. And that "flush" shot from Ruiz you always talk about? :rofl:patsch It landed on his upper chest not his Glass Jaw. Ruiz has a horrible KO rate and that is why Jones handpicked the fight. I will quote Floyd Mayweather Sr. on this topic (paraphrased) "Once Roy started getting hit on the Chin he also started getting knocked out".

    :dance
     
  9. tylerrcurtis

    tylerrcurtis Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,533
    2
    Aug 15, 2008
    i think could take toney(we saw this so we knew he could) byrd(due to birds smaller size basically he was a poor mans RJJ) also i think he could take golota and rahaman and brewster if he could stay away from the power and holyfield at this point..and also MAYBE would be able to take tyson as tyson was on the downhill
     
  10. kingpwc

    kingpwc PERSEVERANCE Full Member

    348
    0
    Jan 4, 2007
    well considering after the ruiz fight......there was talk about...

    tyson/rjj....megafight......

    if ....and its a big if......rjj got pass the 5th he'd might win.....


    he knows....uno...ino....we kno.....if he would get hit by the power of tyson...it would of been a wrap....which would of likely happened...

    tyson even at the stage was faster than all the heavyies.....


    there was talk about 50 million per fighter.....

    but the fight didnt happen......

    so we will debate his thru out history..


    he'd beat byrd and .....and maybe some of the less athleticly gifted heavies.....

    who knos......

    imo.....
     
  11. Brickhaus

    Brickhaus Packs the house Full Member

    22,296
    5
    Mar 14, 2007
    Roy MIGHT have been able to beat early Wladimir, before he turned his jab into a killer defensive weapon.
     
  12. DINAMITA

    DINAMITA Guest

    I think Lewis and Vitali Klitschko would 100% definitely have beaten the RJJ that beat Ruiz.

    I think Wladimir Klitschko, Corrie Sanders and David Tua would probably have beaten that RJJ. (The Wlad of right now would definitely beat the '03 RJJ, but the Wlad of '03 was a glass-jawed nervous wreck with no jab and no defence. As I said, size and strength mean he would probably have beaten RJJ anyway though). Sanders also had size on his side, and Tua probably would have gotten to Jones with his leaping attacks at one point. Tua was strong enough to hurt Jones at any time, in clinches, any punch would've stung RJJ. I think Tua could've got the job done.


    I would fancy RJJ to do what he did to Ruiz to the 2003 version of all of the rest:

    Tyson, Holyfield, Toney, Rahman, Brewster, Golota.

    Tyson was shot and would be outboxed for every second of every round, same with Holyfield.

    As much as I love Toney, the heavyweight version would have even less chance of beating Jones than the supermiddleweight version - Jones's speed and mobility mean this is an unwinnable fight for JT.

    Much like the Ruiz fight, Jones would be quick, careful and incisive, and widely outpoint Rahman, Brewster and Golota. The Golota who fought Bowe would have beaten Jones '03 on size and strength, but Golota by '03 was a shadow of that guy. Jones would've boxed rings round Rahman and Brewster all night long. They would've had a puncher's chance sure, but I wouldn't fancy either of them to land a good shot.



    In conclusion, YES, he could've had a good career - but IMO it would've involved a bit of strategic "cherry-picking", as the superheavyweights were simply too big, and David Tua would be a bad stylistic match.

    If RJJ had beat Tyson, Holyfield, Golota and Rahman, he would've been hailed as a top 10 p4p of all-time for sure IMO. And I honestly think he could have.

    :good
     
  13. jimmie

    jimmie Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    16,706
    1
    Jul 19, 2004
    WBC Champion - Lennox Lewis - Lewis was to big and powerful for Jones. I see this as a brutal massacre Lewis owning Roy with that long jab and brutally KOing him with a right hand in the 4th.
    WBO Champion - Wladimir Klitschko - Wlad would do basically what Lewis would do just Roy may have a better chance considering the level that Wlad was at back then. Wlad has poor defense,stamina and his chin was pathetic. Id give Roy a chance if he could last past 5 to wear Wlad down with some body shots and maybe get a stoppage. However 9 times out of 10 Wlad KOs him early.
    IBF Champion - Chris Byrd - Byrd was quick and had fantastic defense but Roy even at Heavyweight had heavy hands and would probablly outwork Byrd to a somewhat close decision like 116-112.
    Vitali Klitschko - Same with Lewis and Wlad hes just way to big,strong and powerful for Roy Jones he finishes him around the 4th or 5th.
    James Toney - All that really needs to be said is their first fight. Roy shut him out,dropped him and made him look like a complete piece of crap as a fighter. Weight wouldnt make much or atleast that much of a difference. RJJ UD agian.
    Mike Tyson - At that point id actually go with Roy. Tysons speed had dimished big time he only had stamina for about 3 rounds maybe even less plus he was injury prone. As long as Roy can use his legs and play a real low risk fighting style for a couple he will tire and fustrate Tyson. I see Roy just pot shoting right hands for the most part and occasionally ripping Tyson with 3-4 punch combos before Mike quits on his stool after 8.
    Evander Holyfield - Roy would outwork him and outland at atleast 3-1 rate and easily win a UD.
    Hasim Rahman - Rahman would always be dangerous with his powerful right hand but I believe Roy is superior in almost every other way. Roy would do something similar to the Ruiz fight but quite possible stop Rahman late.
    Corrie Sanders - Sanders could murder him inside 2 rounds but like many on this list he goes to **** after that. Its simple if Roy survives the storm he goes on to win this fight and handily.
    Lamon Brewster - Roy should outbox him because Brewster has no real boxing ability. Thing is Brewster is a man who throws punches with conviction all the way to the end. Id give Brewster a very good chance to take Roys head off with a left hook but id lean towards Roy UD.
    David Tua - See Lamon Brewster.
    Andrew Golota - Golota has never won a big fight and I cant even see him winning agianst the much smaller Jones. I see him finding a way to give away several rounds and loses a decision if he doesnt quit before then.
     
  14. MasterFlo

    MasterFlo Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,073
    2
    Dec 11, 2007
    I don't understand the scores against Ruiz, 116-112? It wasn't even close, I'm assuming all of you have seen the fight and are aware of this. I thought it was 118-110 and I couln't see it being more towards Ruiz.

    Anyway Jones would have beaten Byrd, Rachman and Toney for sure, easy decisions. I favour Roy over Sanders and Brewster but they have a punchers chance for sure, glass jaw or not I couldn't see Roy absorbing a clean shot from either but I also don't think they would have gotten a clean shot. Tua, Holyfeild and Tyson are all 50/50 for me. Holy and Tyson were older at this point and on the decline, if they could fight like their old selves for one night the fight is theirs. If Tua came in overweight he simply has no chance, Roy would box circles around him, if he came in fit his punches would wear Roy down landed or not. Lewis and the Klitschkos are too big, they wouldn't let Roy in often and even if they did, Roy wouldn't have the power to capitalize. He also could not sustain their weight during the clinches. As for Golota I simply have no idea, he fights so tall I don't see Roy getting near him but he's also too slow to catch Roy, it would be boring and we would all lose for seeing it unless Andrew went crazy again.
     
  15. jimmie

    jimmie Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    16,706
    1
    Jul 19, 2004
    116-112 was a disgrace. I gave Ruiz that late round that Roy gave to him.