Scenario: Hatton beats Pac and Floyd stays Retired...who is P4P #1?

The winner of Bradley-Holt is a tougher fight for Hatton than Manny Pacquiao, yes.

****, yes. Do I really need to defend that statement? atsch

 

Wow Hooligan's avatar is just f*cked up lol. I would say Hatton is def. top 5 with JMM, Pacman, Calzaghe, and maybe Dawson if he beats Pacman. Manny still stays in top 5 though even if he loses to Hatton at 140 pounds.

 

IMO, its JMM, but we all know Oscar will give it to Haton

 

If Calzaghe doesn't have a fight lined up mid year I'll take him off. Put Hatton above Pac and Marquez at #1.

 

If Hatton dominated Pac and JMM beat Diaz which is very likely, then JMM should be #1. Hatton would probably move up to #3 or 4.

 

Hatton would be number 3, i think CalZ has to go one year without fighting before he is removes from the list, so Hatton would be number 3, and JMM would be ranked number 1. HBO will start blowing up JMM and all the boxing sites will start talking about how he was robbed in both fights against Pac, and then JMM will have a fanbase bigger than ever and he'll be in line to fight Hatton for alot of money!

 

JMM. Fought Pac on equal grounds and could've arguably received a decision in both their fights. Plus he became lineal champ after beating the man at 135. Best technical fighter in the world. I also expect him to beat Diaz in their upcoming fight.

Hatton breaks into the top 5 if he wins but I think he may need to beat JMM to get number 1. Pac slips to top 3 or 4. Highly doubt he'll slip below top 5 unless he gives a shamelessly awful performance which seems impossible for a guy like Pac.

Joe is retiring so we really shouldn't bother putting him in the equation.

 

Koki Kameda

 

it should be JMM

 

How is Dawson top five?? Not a chance.

There are at least another ten fighters I'd have ahead of Dawson in a P4P list aside from the ones you've already mentioned.

For me, if Hatton were to beat Pac convincingly Hatton goes to #3 P4P behind Pac and Calzaghe in that order.

 

jmm if he beat juan diaz, hatton will not be #1 p4p just for beating pac. pac got there by beating a lot of good fighters coupled with the retirement of pbf. hatton cannot be #1 because of 1 fight.

 

Calzhage I guess perhaps hatton!:good

 

joe cal

 

jmm