Scorecards please!

close one on urs

 

Your opinion stinks.

 

Marquez - Pacquaio
1st: 9-10
2nd: 10-9
3rd: 8-10
4th: 9-10
5th: 10-9
6th: 10-9
7th: 10-9
8th: 10-9
9th: 9-10
10th: 9-10
11th: 10-9
12th: 10-9

114-113 Marquez

 

Heres how I saw it:

Clear rounds are: 2,5,6,7,12 were clear rounds for JMM. 3,4,10 & 11 clear for Pac with 3 having a KD score. 1, 7 & 9 were very close rounds, so to be fair I split it, I gave 1 to JMM, 9 to Pac & score 7th even. Overall card looked like this:

Pac-JMM
1) 9-10
2) 9-10
3) 10-8
4) 10-9
5) 9-10
6) 9-10
7) 9-9
8) 9-10
9) 10-9
10) 10-9
11) 10-9
12) 9-10

Total: 113-113

The score was a draw. Now based on those 3 rounds being switched around, taking out the even, any fighter could have gotten it and it would have still been a very close fight. IMO this was more of a draw than their last fight, I scored their first fight 1 point to Pac but this is exactly a draw. As it is, records will have it SD for Pac here and 1st being a draw.

That 115-112 scorecard looks completely plausible if someone gave Pac all the close rounds. Likewise 115-112 to JMM is also completely plausible if someone have all close rounds to JMM. Split the close rounds between them and you get my score.

IMO JMM is a nightmare for Pac to fight. A masterful boxer but with deceivingly fast speed(almost as fast as Pac) and crisp straight punches. The fact that Pac can draw with him is just a testament to his greatness, stylistic nightmare overcomed. Other great fighters like MAB couldnt nearly have as much success. Its simmilar to PBF getting a draw with Hearns or Hearns getting fighting evens with Hagler, both great fighters, one with a stylistic advantage yet equal result.

 

Pacquiao rounds: 3, 4, 9, 10, 11
Marquez rounds: 1, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 12

Marquez 114 Pacquiao 113

 

good comment

 

So does your mom's vagina

 

So scorecards on PAC-MAB I should have read 120-104? :tong

 

Barrera got knocked out in the 11th how will he accumulate 120 points?

 

For those scoring 8 as a 10-8 - Considering his younger brother got a KD scored against him when the ropes were the only things holding him up in the 12th a few weeks back - One could argue that the 4 was a 10-7 round...

However - My card -

1 Marquez 10-9
2 Marquez 10-9
3 Pac 10-8
4 Pac 10-9
5 Marquez 10-9
6 Marquez 10-9
7 Pac 10-9
8 Marquez 10-9
9 Pac 10-9
10 Pac 10-9
11 Marquez 10-9
12 Marquez 10-9


Marquez 114 - 113

I have no issue with the scores as they were, VERY tight rounds in there along the way.

 

exactly the way you had it except for R1

 

I had it 114-113 Marquez, Cant argue with the decision as it was a very close fight with rounds that coulda gone either way. I just hope we get the rematch.

 

I've got it that way but gave the 11th to Pac.