Quite a few good scorers such as @IntentionalButt @CST80 even had it a draw or for parker as well as others i quoted so i dont think we need to learn how to score. @Dfaulds
You're only calling them good because they agree with you... A small minority agreeing with eachother doesn't make the result right. The vast majority, including Parker and his team (and NZ media) felt AJ won comfortably... That says it all really.
Im saying @IntentionalButt and @CST80 are two of the best scorers on this website not just due to this one fight but because of the consistently good scoring done since probably before i joined this website. I guarantee that most members probably think that an all. So im not just saying their good because they agreed with me man. Try rewatching the fight and posting youre round by round unbiased scoring on here. Just wouldnt mind comparing our scores and see where we differ.
we’ll probably just have to agree to disagree on the AJ/Parker tho judging by how differently we score it pal.
I had Parker up as well. Round 1 Parker 10-9 Round 2 Parker 10-9 Round 3 Joshua 10-9 Round 4 Joshua 10-9 Round 5 Parker 10-9 Round 6 Parker 10-9 Round 7 Parker 10-9 Round 8 Joshua 10-9 Round 9 Parker 10-9 Round 10 Joshua 10-9 Round 11 Parker 10-9 Round 12 Joshua 10-9
R1 - AJ R2 - AJ close R3 - AJ R4 - AJ R5 - JP close R6 - JP R7 - AJ R8 - AJ R9 - JP close R10 - AJ R11 - AJ R12 - AJ 117-111 AJ. I gave Parker round 2 and AJ rounds 5&9 last time I scored it for 118-110 AJ. They were close enough that this time I scored it different. All the other rounds weren't debatable for me, so giving Parker all the close rounds plus round 6, still leaves me giving Parker at best a 112-116 loss.
never saw this one, just watched the 1st one and thanks for the suggestion McDonnell kameda 9 10 Close 9 10 8 10 10 9 Close 10 9 Close 9 10 10 9 10 9 10 9 10 9 Close 10 9 10 9 115 112 Great fight to watch and non stop action throughout. Felt like kameda started at a fast pace at the beginning and feeling more comfortable landing the more powerful punches, working the body and landing the more accurate punches to take the early rounds along with the right hand which put McDonnell down in the 3rd round but in the second half of the fight McDonnell took over and upped the workrate as well as kameda seemingly slowing down and not being able to maintain his own workrate as well as losing that punching power he had at the beginning which kept McDonnell at bay which meant that McDonnell ran away with the second half of the fight. McDonnell also grew into the fight making the necessary adjustments to counter what kameda was doing whereas kameda struck to his game planning throughout and never had a plan b. But the reach and height did play a hand in McDonnell being able to take control of this fight. Overall kameda showed great handspeed, nice combinations, good bodywork and solid ring iq and defence whereas McDonnell displayed a good gas tank, good bodywork of his own, nice jab and straight and footwork to keep outnumbered of kamedas range especially in the second half of the fight. I have no problem with a Close kameda win as the early rounds could have also gone kamedas win but overall McDonnell did enough to win this one. What scores did everyone else have for this one?
Relikh-Troyanovsky 115-113 Troyanovsky Tete-Aloyan 114-111 Aloyan Tabiti-Fayfer 114-113 Tabiti Vargas-Dulorme 116-110 Dulorme Broner-Vargas 117-111 Vargas Mchunu-Oosthuizen 116-112 Oosthuizen Nietes-Palicte 115-113 Palicte Menayothin-Taduran 115-111 Menayothin Kownacki-Martin 95-95 Draw Avagyan-Smirnov 97-93 Avagyan Borrego-Krael 96-94 Borrego Estrada-Orucuta 116-112 Estrada
McDonnell vs Kameda 1 R1 & R2 - Kameda R3 - Kameda 10-8 R4-R7 - McDonnell R8 - Kameda R9-R12 - McDonnell 115-112 McDonnell McDonnell vs Kameda 2 R1&R2 - Kameda R3 - McDonnell R4&R5 - Kameda R6 - McDonnell R7 - Kameda R8 - McDonnell R9 - Kameda R10&R11 - McDonnell R12 - McDonnell 10-8 114-113 McDonnell
Similar scores besides the mchunu and aloyan fights. The mchunu one is hard to score and could easily go oosthuizens way but the aloyan fight im surprised yer had it that score for aloyan. Aloyan seemed way too inactive in that one. Thanks for all the figts youve suggested tho pal
