Serious debate: Can Froch be finished? Can Kessler do it? How good is Carl Froch?

Discussion in 'British Boxing Forum' started by craney91, Feb 20, 2013.


  1. craney91

    craney91 Boxing Addict banned

    4,934
    0
    Mar 23, 2012
    Taylor showed the world he can be knocked down and wobbled, the key is to follow that up, which Taylor didn't. He ended up throwing it away, getting complacent, letting Froch back in and gassing late on. Those same signs were shown against Kelly Pavlik also.

    Froch came back and showed the heart of a champion in that fight, and that cannot be denied. And credit where credit is due, Froch has taken some massive shots, because of his awkward style, and because of that he will always be open to taking big shots, with the wide stance and the arms being down, the key is to connect when he leaves the chin out.....and he does leave it out A LOT.

    I dont believe Froch has improved as much as some people are making out.

    He destroyed Arthur Abraham after losing his first fight as a pro against Mikkel Kessler. And there is no doubting Carl's heart, that is as good as anyones in the sport. But lets be real to. Arthur Abraham is average and a stereotypical European fighter. But as for Carl's ability, I honestly think he can be got.

    Andre Ward proved that.
    Jermaine Taylor also proved that.

    Since the Jean Pascal fight whcih he won in Nottingham by UD -

    Carl won the Jermain Taylor fight in the last round in the US
    A split decision win over Andre Dirrell in Nottingham
    Was beat by Mikkel Kessler in Denmark
    Beat Abraham in Finland
    Won a MD over Glen Johnson in the US
    Lost to Andre Ward in the US
    Beat Bute in Nottingham
    Beat Mack in Nottingham

    So people are saying "Carl Froch has improved and Mikkel Kessler has declined" ?

    But my question is, can you really say Froch has improved in 2 fights, Bute and Mack?

    I mean come on, that is awful opposition, Bute was one of the most pampered domesticated champions in the sport. Mack is awful. Carl should have been dominating those fights. And he did.

    I guess we will see just how much Carl has "improved" in this next fight.

    I know this might be harsh, but I can assure you I'm not trolling - is Carl Froch all that?

    Great chin, great heart. But what else?

    I'm not a fanboy or a hater, I'm a total neutral. And I am purely looking at it like that. I rate Carl Froch in areas, and give him plenty of credit, but in others he is average.

    I honestly believe Kessler can beat Froch in the rematch, and not only beat him, but finish the fight on away ground.

    But what do you think?

    Keep it clean, and above all, protect yourselves at all times.

    This is a serious debate, please do not wreck it. If you want to be off topic, do it elsewhere :good
     
  2. DOM5153

    DOM5153 They Cannot Run Forever Full Member

    12,340
    1
    Jan 9, 2009
    You do raise some interesting points especially the ones regarding Froch's improvements. I do believe Carl has improved a little bit since the Kessler defeat and learnt a lot about not loading up on single punches in his defeat against Ward. The Bute fight highlighted the improvement in his combination punching, had he not faced the elusive Ward before that point he may not have blasted Bute out in quite emphatic fashion. One of the many things i admire about Froch and his trainer specifically is the ability to go back to the drawing board and to improve on areas that were once weak, the Ward fight may have been a blessing in disguise. The combinations are smoother, not as clunky with his movements and not as much emphasis on loading up with single shots. The improvements would be clear regardless of opposition in my honest opinion.

    With regards to Kessler declining i believe this to be true, without going into too much detail this has been evident withing his last couple of efforts. His biggest hope is that Froch's punch resistance is starting to decline due to his age and the high level he's been operating at for a while now. Im sure Montoya is working on a gameplan to stop Carl in his tracks with hard body shots and jabs to the chest area, if Kessler can keep Carl on the backfoot (which i dont think he can anymore) he may be able to bring hard straight right and the booming left hook into play, but as we saw with the 1st fight Carl is one tough ****er who wont be put off in the slightest by a big shot or two.
     
  3. Nafflad26

    Nafflad26 Active Member Full Member

    1,314
    0
    Aug 22, 2012
    I don't think Froch is really 35 in boxing terms. He seems to be physically improving with every fight and I think that is a big reason why he has continued to slightly improve. The fact that he carries very little weight between fights is a massive thing because he doesn't abuse his body like other fighters. I've said it in previous threads and I'll say it again its unbelievable to think that Ricky Hatton is younger than Carl Froch!
     
  4. craney91

    craney91 Boxing Addict banned

    4,934
    0
    Mar 23, 2012
    I think I was a bit harsh, Froch isnt just a great chin and heart. He is in tremendous physical condition even before fights. And he has a great determination during fights. He comes prepared and he stays in shape between fights. He takes it seriously and that should be admired. He has power to, even if his punches look ugly, he can hit.

    But fundamentally boxing skill wise I've never thought Carl Froch was ELITE level. He is punching above his weight because of what he is about. Nothing wrong with that, he deserves the big fights, but we have seen what happens when he is matched up against someone truly elite. Its chalk and cheese. He gets picked apart because defensively he is average IMO.
     
  5. fortysixando

    fortysixando Active Member Full Member

    1,039
    0
    Sep 20, 2011
    i dont think kessler can beat him let alone finish him but by the end of the year i reckon george groves will be ready
     
  6. craney91

    craney91 Boxing Addict banned

    4,934
    0
    Mar 23, 2012
    Really?

    Why do you think that is?

    Me personally, I think Groves would get steamrollered, Groves is like a baby and he needs to be spoon fed by Adam Booth. He is so open and lazy I think Froch would beat him quite bad. Mental toughness, and as soon as Groves gets hit, thats it, fight over IMO he will get pummeled. Both fighters are open, but I worry more for Groves taking punches.

    Some people are saying Froch has improved greatly, me personally, I just don't see it. Especially in the Bute and Mack fights. Those fights dont show us much IMO. Blowouts.
     
  7. Nafflad26

    Nafflad26 Active Member Full Member

    1,314
    0
    Aug 22, 2012
    Kenny Anderson put Groves down so that doesn't bode well for him if he fights Froch.
     
  8. True_Hero

    True_Hero Guest

    Froch wins late round stoppage. I can just see Kessler been busted open again since his eyes are ****ed thanks to Andre "Headbutt" Ward :(

    Which is a shame, because this could easily be a fight of the year contender. So my prediction is late stoppage or Froch winning on points. I love Kessler, he's one of my favs but I just don't think he has what it takes to stop Froch.
     
  9. BlackBrenny

    BlackBrenny Guest

    I don't think he has improved THAT much either, nor do I think Kessler has declined to an extent where Froch can beat him close but clear. Hell, I'm not sure Froch can still beat him at all, my money is on Kessler, but I can see why others pick Froch.

    It's not so much that Abraham is a stereotypical European fighter, it's just that he's pretty **** at supermiddle in terms of world level, but it was a good performance from Froch (MANY people picked Abraham to blitz him)

    The Johnson MD was harsh, Carl clearly won that fight

    Against Ward, well, he was outclassed as expected but I think he did in fact learn from that fight.

    Then came Bute, I'll admit, I thought Bute would outbox Froch, not just because Bute to me looked very good, but also because Froch was coming off a pretty confidence shattering defeat. I should have known better than to question the "Warrior" himself, he absolutely blitzed Bute and it was an exciting thing to see, Bute just wilted under both Carls pressure, and the big occassion. Still, to call Bute "awful" is over-stating it a bit.


    Now Kessler is obviously not the same fighter the great Joe Calzaghe beat, but he's far, far from finished. He still brings the pain. One thing about Kessler that has noticeably declined is his speed and most of all, reactions. A worrying thing in the Allan Green fight was how he stopped using his jab and started throwing a pretty telegraphed left hook over and over again. Green somehow still managed to get himself KO'd by this.

    Against Magee, Kessler looked better and much sharper, one of the reasons for this I believe was that he was very motivated to fight the "Dane Killer" and he had gotten his confidence back after the Green KO. There is no question that Kessler is going to be bang up for this fight, and I have a feeling he's going to turn back the clock and win a close but clear fight in another war with Froch

    Can he stop Froch? I doubt it although with Kesslers power anything is possible? Despite Froch being hurt not only by Taylor but by Dirrell, you cant fight like him and not expect to be buzzed once in a while. And let's face it, he has already went toe to toe with Kessler who hits much harder than those two, but maybe Frochs wars will catch up to him on the night? If anybody can do it, its certainly Kessler

    How good is Carl Froch? Well we all know how tough he is, how determined he is, and how much heart he has, but as Tarver says, "he has subtle skills". Remember, Froch was a world amateur bronze medallist, you don't win those things with toughness alone, you gotta have skills, and he does, he just has one of those styles that makes it hard to spot.

    He's definately a top world class fighter, but so is Kessler still, should be a good one.
     
  10. BlackBrenny

    BlackBrenny Guest

    Those eyes are certainly a concern thanks to the ****ing billygoater, Ward should have been pulled for that way more than he was after the fight, he did permanent damage to Kessler
     
  11. craney91

    craney91 Boxing Addict banned

    4,934
    0
    Mar 23, 2012
    Great post Brenny, good analysis. :good

    Like I always say, any fighter can have an off-night. Carl Froch has had his fair share. The very best have had theirs to. So I'm sure Kessler will be allowed a few. His "decline" may have just been an off-night, people jump to conclusions. As we know Brenny :hey :lol:

    At the end of the day, Froch is not unbeatable, hasn't improved to the extent some are making out, and whilst he has a solid chin, he can be got at. Ward proved that. Kessler proved that in the first fight, Taylor did and also Pascal. Had Bute been as mentally tough, I'm pretty sure he would have got through aswell in that fight. Froch was so open for a counter uppercut or hook, but Bute was scared of the Cobra and out of his comfort zone.

    Froch has been hurt more than a few times IMO, but he is a master of not showing it much, when he sits back down between the round he is wary and awake, asking questions, explaining what happened. Is he in denial? Is the bravado taking over? Is he even embarrassed?......I'm not hurt.....no really Rob.....honest.... :lol:

    One thing is for certain Carl Froch is a tough fighter, not just physically, but also mentally. And I can see why people say he is a warrior. No need for him to say it so much though. :lol:

    The key for me in the Kessler rematch, is the jab, Kessler's is on another level. It has meaning. Carl's is awkward, ugly, he leaves it out, he measures with it. But it doesnt count if it doesnt land. And Kessler can take a page out of Wards book, by slipping the jab and getting 2-3 punches of whilst the lazy arm is hanging out. If Froch has learned from that, he wont do it.

    One thing is for sure, Kessler wont be fazed by the occasion. This is somebody who fought Joe Calzaghe in Wales. And Joe is several levels above Carl Froch in my eyes and Joe even admits it was one of his toughest fights alongside Eubank.

    They certainly don't call him the "Viking Warrior" for nothing, but he seems to cut easily and a lot of people have pointed that out in the lead up to this 2nd fight. I hope a cut doesn't spoil the occasion and we get a fight like the 1st.

    But right from the moment this fight was announced, I've had a sneaky feeling that Kessler is gonna shock a lot of people, and finish the fight with a cracking punch.

    If it ends that way, either way, or a 12 round war, one thing is for sure, it will be a brilliant spectacle, and a great fight to watch, for however long it lasts.

    CANT ****ING WAIT!
     
  12. Bronxbull666

    Bronxbull666 The Beast From The East Full Member

    1,338
    1
    Jun 1, 2012
    I'm not sure Froch has improved, that remains to be seen if he fights Ward again. I think Froch does look more fresh and hungry. I think Kessler is on the slide, Bute was well overrated and I couldn't believe he was the favourite. Kessler will leave himself wide open to a sustained attack, I don't think Froch will get KOd by Kessler. My money is on a Froch win in rounds 7-9.
     
  13. Jonny5-9

    Jonny5-9 Active Member Full Member

    734
    0
    Oct 25, 2012
    Froch SHOULD win this. He could of won the first one but his timing seemed of and he couldnt seem to pull the trigger.

    Since then Froch has improved and Kessler has gone downhill. Kessler is also plagued by injuries and the cuts caused by Billy Goat Ward are a concern.

    Plus although not in Nottingham, Froch has home support which does make a difference.
     
  14. trotter

    trotter Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,762
    2
    Apr 18, 2008
    Froch is much more experienced, he's improved physically too, on home soil, I favour him quite strongly in this rematch.

    OP you can't just label his opposition (Bute, Abraham) as awful because he beat them so easily. Revisionism at its finest.

    And the question can Froch be taken out, well, anyone can. But Taylor caught him quite cold due to a mix of, well, stage fright - and a habit of starting slow. Froch has corrected both those factors IMO.
     
  15. Ireland

    Ireland Guest

    I think Froch is overated when it comes to people calling him an all time great, one of the reasons is that people rate him so highly is his courage to fight the best, the fact he going in for a rematch with Kessler shows courage as its not a fight he is favoured to win.

    That said i believe Froch will win a highly disputed decision, would not be surprised to see a 3rd fight later this year.