Shakur Stevenson is the best boxer in the world

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Joeywill, Jul 13, 2025.


  1. tragedy

    tragedy Active Member Full Member

    954
    676
    Mar 18, 2024
    Premature what?
     
  2. Toney F*** U

    Toney F*** U Boxing junkie Full Member

    7,178
    11,402
    Oct 16, 2019
    With Usyk and Crawford likely on their way out already, he might have an argument for the most skilled fighter p4p. His only real threat to that crown is Bivol, who actually has the resume to back it up.
     
    Pimp C and Joeywill like this.
  3. tinman

    tinman Loyal Member Full Member

    35,788
    28,418
    Feb 25, 2015
    Bivol is the best fighter still in his prime. At their best guys like Crawford and Usyk were better. And frankly, so was Beterbiev. But right now I'd have to give it to Bivol.
     
    gollumsluvslave and Joeywill like this.
  4. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    79,182
    129,197
    Jul 21, 2009
    So it's not impressive beating your opponent's in their backyard on a deck which is stacked against you, where we know for a fact that the chances of you losing, via hook or crook, are that much higher and the chances of you getting robbed by the judges, the referees waving off fights early in the home fighter's favour, not counting KDs you've scored or counting bogus ones your opponent has for them, the referees turning a convenient blind eye to your opponent fouling the crap out of you all night, octopus grabbing you to death, billy goat butting, elbow, punch low etc. are way higher than they are in your own country/backyard


    We can't give credit to foreigners for doing this playing by a set of rules all the time that American fighters won't do, have never done once, or ever will do once in their entire careers

    You won't give credit to Loma for doing something he hasn't done, which FTR, I'm not even asking anyone to do but rather just that they don't be ignorant pricks and ignore context, very important context, which to be fair at least you have now done

    But we should give credit to American fighters for doing something they've never done once or ever will do because they would do it if they had to even though I've posted numerous examples of some their greatest fighters or best from previous eras, or current best who categorically refused to even travel outside the US or to their foreign opponent's backyards which they never did once, let alone agreeing to fight them on a stacked deck with a home ref and three home judges which they would NEVER do

    Including footage of one categorically refusing to travel to the country of a fighter they're calling out even though said fighter they're calling out was not only the champion at the weight and they were the challenger but they were literally the undisputed champion and held all the belts they wanted at the time

    And it wouldn't have mattered where they fought because the American was simply better and would've beaten them anyway even though they wouldn't dare fight them in their backyard and only did so in theirs on a deck heavily stacked in their favour

    You say Shakur would travel to his opponent's backyards, which he may well one day, a whopping once or possibly twice but never in a million years on one stacked with a home ref and three home judges, but then I provide you with footage of him calling out a 118 pounder initially saying he'd fight them in their country before immediately correcting himself and saying errrr... no, I really don't know about that,

    What compelled him to have second thoughts about that? Why did he suddenly have reservations about doing so? He obviously sees it as very advantageous to Inoue and very disadvantageous to him and that was travelling to fight a fighter who was still at 118 pounder whilst he was at 135 four divisions above him :lol:

    Funny how when a reporter asked Loma if he was open to fight Inoue and move down to 126 to do so and he replied maybe he was absolutely crucified for it by many fans even though he didn't actually call Inoue out or to move up in weight to face him and when we saw them standing alongside each other Loma was barely that much bigger than him and he himself was routinely fighting opponents who were bigger, much or way bigger than he was than Inoue, whereas, conversely, Shakur has been big for every weight class he's fought in or at worst the same size facing guys he was bigger than, not much or way bigger

    But when Shakur literally did call Inoue out, said tell him to move up four divisions to fight him, and in complete contrast to Loma expressed reluctance about travelling to fight in an opponent's backyard, and even worse he's much bigger than Loma is, in his own words Loma is too small, looks like a 126 pounder, should move down to 130 where he would be way better, and he felt way bigger than Loma even though he'd just moved up to 126


    All we heard was crickets
     
    CST80 likes this.
  5. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    79,182
    129,197
    Jul 21, 2009
    But you're giving credit to American fighters for doing something they didn't do, haven't done, categorically refused to ever do once, or will never do once in their careers because they would do it if they had to

    Again, I'm not asking people to give him credit for something he didn't do, just don't ignore context

    What do you mean I guess it's possible? Shakur is a three weight champion beating Joet Gonzalez, Herring, and De Los Santos all in his home country whilst being big for every weight class or at worst the same size at 135 and Loma was good enough to become a three weight world champion in what would be his 4th, 5th, and 6th weight classes had he turned pro at the same age as Shakur whilst being average sized, small and tiny for the weight classes very often being the much or smaller or way smaller man and winning them all in his opponent's backyards or on the road

    Loma has never lost to a fighter his size in his life other than possibly his lone loss in the amateurs, let alone smaller or way smaller. He should only have 2 losses in his 420 + fights as it is and all of his 3 losses in the pros came against fighters who weighed way more than him, at least 2 divisions heavier or 4 in Haney's case, 2 of which in what would be, duh, as explained, be in at least his sixth division had he turned pro at the same age as Shakur and that's without being a weight bully like so many other multiple weight champs, many of whom are also proven PED cheats.

    You think he wouldn't have won world titles had he turned pro three weights lower at the same age as Shakur who is much bigger than him and has always been bigger?

    Did you see Loma at 126 after the Salido fight and 130? He was incredible and he literally toyed with everyone like they were lacing up the gloves for the first time. Look what he did smaller Rigo who was P4P #4 if you want to see a rare instance of him in with a smaller fighter. He made an amazing talent and super skilled power punching defensive whizz like Rigo look like a rank novice. Rigo could barely lay a glove on a Loma who was literally in 1st and 2nd gear.

    There's a reason why he won over 400 amateur fights and only lost once, went from the P4P#1 amateur and pro in just 12 fights, whilast excellent Shakur was never close to being the amateur and he has not come close to becoming the P4P#1 pro in 24 fights and over an 8 year career,

    Why Loma is the quickest two weight one, and the quickest ever three weight one

    The amateur GOAT

    And why when he was at his natural weight he won Olympic gold, World Amateur gold, European gold whilst only conceding a combined 24 points in total in all three of them and he's not a runner or an octopus. Do you understand how insane that is or how insane it is to win over 400 amateur fights, only lose once, avenge that loss twice, and win gold in every tournament you ever entered and the only time he didn't he won silver

    Watch

    One solitary silver medal in an ocean of gold

    Timestamped

    This content is protected



    I get that there are a lot of brainwashed fans out there who when I claim Loma would've been a six weight champ had he turned pro at the same age as Shakur, again, bare minimum, they're like nah, he ain't good enough to achieve that but these people are complete morons (not aiming this at you) and they can't be taken remotely seriously. Loma would've been even more dominant against opponents his size and smaller and he would EASILY have achieved this had he turned pro much younger than he did.

    Shakur with his ''incredible skills'' had just over a third of the amateur fights as Loma did and lost 13 times and Loma fought at the highest level much longer


    How in god's name doesn't Loma become at least a three weight champ by the age Shakur is now if he turned pro at the same age? It makes zero sense and unlike Shakur he would do it in his opponent's backyards or on the road vs opponents his size

    Shakur became a three weight champ by beating Joet Gonzalez, Herring and De Los Santos. Loma would knock out or stop all of them :lol:
     
    CST80 and LoveThis like this.
  6. LoveThis

    LoveThis Sweet Science Full Member

    191
    241
    Feb 20, 2025
    @Serge It's pretty impressive how you argue your point over and over just to crash against the same belief system again and again.

    It does not matter where the money is and if fighters just travel for the money and I am sure most of them do, since it's their income and that's perfectly okay.

    What matters is that it is hard (!) to consistently win under unfavorable conditions and it is easy to do it with everything working for you instead (don't forget the matchmaking on top).

    That is what they should be credited for: not the intent and motivation but the actual achievement. Giving away control and still winning on the night.

    Some boxers fight in their comfort zone all their lifes.

    I assume there is a good bit of US entitlement in there, expecting everyone to bow to their whims.

    But I also feel like this is the same mindset that makes people call Shakur Stevenson the best boxer in the world after winning against zepeda or credit canelo way over his achievements being the absolute a-side with every advantage in the book or defend tank davis for his amazing choice of opponents to then criticize lomachenko for not fighting him at the end of his career and so on...

    Boxer's fandom and patriotism leading to mental gymnastics to explain why A is better than B or why B is not as good as others rate him...

    So tiresome to keep arguing against...
     
    CST80 and Serge like this.
  7. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    79,182
    129,197
    Jul 21, 2009
    Thanks. Well said

    Yeah, it's incredibly tedious having to explain this all again and again and deal with such ignorant opinions when deep down they all know I'm right and that I'm not being remotely unreasonable. But instead of admitting it and just saying you've made a very good point or points they try and make out I'm the bad guy and are mad at me for bringing up this issue and explaining things they choose to conveniently ignore or dismiss because their favs are not the ones fighting on this heavily stacked and unfair deck nor ever will and getting robbed of a huge part of their legacies all the time

    I've never once tried to argue that robberies and corruption don't occur everywhere it's the stacking of the deck with a home ref and three home judges the majority of the time for world title fights between home and away fighters in the US which only happens over there which I'm against and so should they be too. Plenty of it occurs over here in the UK for goodness sake

    They watch these foreigners get robbed time and time again over there often in legacy defining fights and they're totally OK with it because all that matters is that their boys get the win via hook or crook and I don't just mean American fans but also fanboys of American fighters from other parts of the world

    Don't get me wrong, loads of American fans call it out when foreigners get robbed over there and I'm referring to a section of them not all

    Everyone with a semi-functioning brain knows that the chances of you losing in your opponent's backyard, whether via hook or crook, are that much higher and the chances of you getting robbed by the judges or stitched up by the ref are way higher than they are at home in your comfort zone on a deck stacked in your favour.

    Why would anyone with an ounce of integrity even attempt to argue otherwise and deny this? Because they simply don't care because it it's not their favs being robbed all the time or fighting on a deck stacked so heavily against then


    There are many different factors which combine to make it so and, as said, just individual ones can and often do mean the difference between winning and losing, becoming a champion, a unified or undisputed one or losing your belt or belts.

    Even things like ring size can make a huge difference. Notice how many were freaking out about Turki's comments regarding a smaller ring. How incredibly unfair but a home ref and three home judges for world title fights for their boys so often is perfectly fair and nothing to see here

    Refs allowing the A side or home fighter to octopus grab all night or foul the crap out of their opponents has meant the difference between god knows how many fighters winning and losing

    Not counting legit KDs or counting bogus ones or administering long or short counts has too

    There are so many ways you can stack and rig the deck but you can also stack it to the extent you're rolling with loaded dice when so much or everything is in your favour. The promoter, the refs, the judges play tag-team to ensure they secure the desired result.
     
    CST80 and LoveThis like this.
  8. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,176
    2,083
    Aug 2, 2021
    You completely overrate traveling

    It's about circumstances

    Yes American boxers can come off as entitled for not wanting to fight outside of the USA but it's really not that big of a deal and generally used by people like you to overrate Usyk or Lomachenko

    If they were American they'd likely do the same
     
    Pimp C, Bokaj and AdamT like this.
  9. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,176
    2,083
    Aug 2, 2021
    You're assuming a lot by saying that Lomachenko would be a 6 division champ had he turned pro young

    He's very injury prone so Im not so sure

    Either way it's on him for being stupid and continuing to have glorified sparring sessions untill he was 25


    Instead of wasting his time with that he should've turned pro at an earlier age and then maybe he'd accomplish what you said he would

    He can have the title as greatest amateur boxer ever it's just not a big deal to most including me
     
    Pimp C and Bokaj like this.
  10. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,176
    2,083
    Aug 2, 2021
    I mean that I guess it's a possibility but I can't say it with such certainty

    Lomachenko would probably win belts at more than 3 weight classes but 6 is a lot and I can't say that with such confidence

    Either way he wasted a lot of his best years in the minor leagues
     
    Last edited: Jul 16, 2025 at 5:47 AM
    Pimp C and Bokaj like this.
  11. AdamT

    AdamT Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    5,743
    10,135
    Sep 18, 2019
    Floyd for example who always fought in vegas would beat his opponents in my back yard, other than Castillo first time lol. He did lose that fight
     
    Joeywill likes this.
  12. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,176
    2,083
    Aug 2, 2021
    There's been nothing favorable about Shakur Stevensons matchmaking

    He's beaten all the best he can

    Not his fault Tank and Loma ducked him
     
    Pimp C, Bokaj and AdamT like this.
  13. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,176
    2,083
    Aug 2, 2021
    If anything a small ring should be a disadvantage to Shakur Stevenson and not in his favor
     
    Bokaj likes this.
  14. AdamT

    AdamT Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    5,743
    10,135
    Sep 18, 2019
    He would absolutely beat both imo, though Tank would have the power to potentially get to him

    He may not be a better amateur than Loma, but I am pretty sure he will end up a much greater pro which is all that matters to me, because I don't give a **** about amateur boxing. Never really have. Kind of watch the olympics if it is on and that's it
     
    Pimp C, Bokaj and Joeywill like this.
  15. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,176
    2,083
    Aug 2, 2021
    Basically the whole arena was against him vs Oscar

    The general public wanted to see him lose to Manny Pacquiao

    If you are a great fighter you can overcome that

    As far as the Castillo fight I thought Mayweather lost by a point but it was very close and certainly not a robbery
     
    Pimp C, Bokaj and AdamT like this.