Shane Mosley: how highly do you rate him all-time p4p?

Should be ahead of Joe and Winky in my opinion. I dont like Shane since he moved up in weight from his original division but his opponents consists of whos who in boxing. Who has joe fought (grandpas not included).. And Winky, its just boring to talk about Winky.

 

every generation has groups of talented but not extrordinarily gifted fighters!!

he goes into the group many other talented fighters... he doesnt stand out as a true

This content is protected

he aint an ATG special individual fighter

 

Shane is being overrated as always. He's not legitimately a top 100 fighter of all time. Definitely not above Trinidad, as has been suggested.

 

Sorry, I was thinking about Hoyas list of opponents. Still Mosley have more solid competition compared to Joe.

 

Well Mosley was a brilliant lightweight. No-one until Mayweather would have been able to give him a really good fight. Sure, he didn't beat brilliant opposition, but he was more dominant there can Tito could have been at welter or junior middle. And when Mosley did move up, he beat De La Hoya far easier than Trinidad did. Had they fought, Mosley would have beaten Trinidad too.

Marquez never dominated a division.

 

Tito was just as dominant at WW as Mosley was at LW, against superior opposition at that. He fought and defeated overall better opposition throughout his career as well, both in terms of quality and quantity(aside from DLH).

Head to head I'd easily favor Tito over Shane, likely by KO. Terrible matchup for Sugar.

 

all time he would be well outside the top 100.
​

 

Johnny Tapia??? Is this pre-heroin Johnny you are referring to?

 

Obviously.

 

thread isn't about how exciting the fights are but how skilled the fighter is, and winky's one of the few legitimately avoided fighters of his time because of the skills he has.

 

What about Pongsaklek Wonjongkam? He won 49 straight fights including 18 title fights in a row. Currently #5 ranked flyweight in the world.