Should dodson get another go at quigley or is it Paul Smith's time?

I think you must be thinking about 2 different fighters. Quigley will get no where near Smith in terms of speed, power, ability, and balls.
If you have wathced Smith at all, and seen the leverage he gets in punches, and seen the manner in which he has stopped some of his opponents, i think it would be a massive mistake to say Smith is not a puncher at all, and quigley would be making a massive mistake if he starts to think the same.

 

Maybe warren would have pushed him by now, maybe not. Who knows what goes on behind the scenes? I think the thing is, and this is the great thing about forums, that we have different opinions, and either of us could be right.
I just happen to think that Smith is someone who is good enough to reach european level Maybe world, depending on how he develops. I didn't see quigley do anything to suggest he could trouble Smith in the slightest in his fight against Dodson. I think that sometimes a boxers KO % tells the trurth, and sometimes is doesn't. It certainly can indicate power, but it depends on if you come up against a defensive fighter, someone who can genuinely take a punch etc. For example if Smith fought someone with the punch resistance of Khan for example, he would have a 100% KO ratio.
Who knows though, Smith may have a night where he gets Quigley in trouble, doesn't finish him, then punches himself out, and Quigley takes him 10 rounds plus, and catches him sweet.
Anything can happen. This is why i love boxing.
Just on this occasion, Quigley is swimming too deep for his ability

 

Fair do's mate, but i am based in liverpool, and this matters to us up here, granted it is not hatton v mayweather 2.
I think the fact we are discussing whether he should or shouldn't get another shot indicates that we know he was KO'D, as we were paying attention when it was on the TV.

 

I think magee comes into it purely because he is regarded by many still as the champ, and whoever is the british champ, if they have anything about them, would want to fight and defeat magee to be regarded as the bona fide champ. Smith quigley as i understand it has to take place before september, and bids need to be submitted by mid may, so we wshould know for sure in about a month, hopefully sooner.
You are right, Smith has waited long enough, am sure he is ****ed off quigley was in there before him.
It will only add to the needle that already exists

 

Don't think Smith would have any issue facing magee. I feel that smith looks stronger at smw, whereas Quigley did look more middleweight fighting at SMW.
Would be a cracking fight whoever fought magee though

 

Not connected to Smith at all. I like him as a fighter. We are allowed to have favourites aren't we. Quite sad you are looking at how much i post about Smith.
Never said Smith woud beat anyone he fights. Wouldn't have much chance at world level at the moment, quite possibly even european level. I Just feel he would grow into it, as the base ingrediants are there for him.
There is no If about Smith beating Quigley, it is how and when. Not saying it is not possible for Quigley to win. Think it isa fair for me to ppose the question, are you connected with Quigley at all? I do not know who else you post about, as i can't be arsed to check, but you seem to be very intent on pushing this argument.
Don't forgoet, Quigley will be facing someone who was ready for this type of opporunity about 6 fights ago, and time makes people hungry.
As for Smith v Magee, my confidence in Smith may well come and bite me on the arse in the future. I just don't think it would be as easy as you are predicting.
But finally on Smith v Quigley. Smigga tko 4-6 rounds, mark my words.
If i am wrong, i will start a thread to appologise.

 

Indeed :yep