Should Haye be above Wlad Klistchko pound for pound?

He`d knock the crap out of Cunningham.The fight wouldn`t sell in Britain that well anyway.Cunningham never beat a big name fighter.

 

Well, Haye is #1 P4P ATG; so, of course.

 

P4P Haye has achieved more then Wlad has. Is'nt that what the P4P list is about ? , Wlad is'nt the undisputed h/w champ.

 

Haye wasnt the undisputed cruiserweight champ either, Cunningham has a belt

 

Love Haye and am very ecited bout his foray into the heavyweight division but there is no way you can rate him above Klitschko. Haye did effectively clean up his division with the possible exception of Cunningham but this is a less renowned division than the heavyweight. Wlad has beaten everyone put in front of him and is on his way to unifying the belts. He has suffered some setback defeats but so did the last undisputed champ Lennox Lewis and he came back from them. Haye has the potential to be great but at the moment he must rate behind Klitschko.

 

Yes, IMO, until Haye officially fights at HW. For now, Haye is 50 pounds lighter than Wlad, which is enough to put him higher on the P4P list. Once he's only 20 pounds lighter, then he's probably not.

 

What are you talking about? Look at Haye's resume, then Wlad's...if you still think that it true you are definitely ******ed or British.

 

umm where do you people base your p4p rankings? resume? skill?

 

I think P4p Haye is higher!

 

I did , and stand by my ' british ' opinion , Wlads 3 KO loss es , in a shite h/w divison.:yep

 

Nope he isn´t, maybe universally recognized but not undiputed. I´m not a boxer and not even a cw but I dispute him

 

even if its a string of probably the worst top 10 heavies ever ?
( not having a dig , its an honest question)

if I understand P4P the theory is if they were the same size who would win , by that rational I think Haye has to edge it.

 

Great, he's a shite fighter, he'll fit right in when he gets knocked the **** out in his first real fight.

 

I agree

but as far as the mouth goes Haye is pound for pound quality

 

See the only reason I would give Haye a chance is because of his speed and decent pop. If they were the same size I don't see him carrying that speed and Wlad's a better boxer by far... so I would say P4P Wlad is above Haye

If we think about it in another context haye might have an argument against Wlad in the P4P rankings as a cruiserweight, but now he's a heavy and hasn't done anything at his current weight so I wouldn't even put him on a P4P ranking