As much as it pains me to say so - but "NO" - Pavlik does not deserve P4P consideration after being dominated like that. Had he put up more of a fight - even in a losing effort - I might have voted differently. He is the middleweight champion still - but P4P - no. Resoundingly - no.
Nope -- he's out of the top 10. Humour me for a minute, and I'll tell ya why I voted no. Let's assume that the elbow injury was much worse than we were originally told, which now appears to be the case. And, let's assume that the bronchitis was also a serious problem, which does appear to be true. If your balls are so much bigger than your brain that you don't know when to post pone a fight, you don't get a spot in the top 10 P4P; period.