Should Ring magazine give JMM his #3 slot back to him?

All factors combined and considered. Yes. Just out of respect.

 

Hmmm thats a good question. I dont know Martinez KO was impressive as hell.

Though based on longetivity in the p4p list i think it should be like this.
3a. JMM
3b. Martinez

 

No. Sergio Martinez deserves the spot.

 

Marquez is good, but a win over Paul Williams means more

 

Pac
JMM
Martinez

Floyd should be removed until he signs to a fight inside the ring

 

Based on the rankings nobody can argue, but this is a good thread regardless.

 

I think JMM should be number 3. But the powers that be may keep Martinez there because he brings a fresh presence to the top pound 4 pound list. He offers us new potential fights against Mayweather or Pacquiao, over what already seeing JMM against them both.

 

I actually agree with this. A few more months w/o any news from Floyd and this is going to be the list.

 

Martinez is probably the better fighter at this point but if we're including longevity and acheivements in the equation, the Juan should be #3.

 

I stay with Sergio. PWill victory means more. PWill was/is ranked in most people's P4P list. Kat is nowhere near it.

 

Most at the top fight twice a year Floyd fought just once.... Big deal.

 

Martinez beat Pavlik and PW. He gets my vote.

 

Paul Williams is a better fighter than Katsidis, so the answer is no. Martinez is the number 2 p4p, maybe his number 3 and move Floyd to number 4.