should we just declare shane mosley p4p no1?

What has Mosley done?

He shouldn't even be in the top 5.

Loss to Cotto, barely beat Mayorga, and beat Margarito who probably cheated his whole career anyway, and was never that good to begin with. And he's been inactive for nearly a year.

 

That is my favorite beatdown ever, I have watched that fight at least 10 times

 

after he revenges his lost from cotto

 

If Mosley wins and Pac also beats Clottey, then I would put Mosley #1 in the WW list and #2 in the P4P list.
Pac would be #2 in WW list and #1 in P4P list.

This assumes Floyd does not fight anyone or fights a lower caliber opponent (Campbell, Malig., Hatton, etc).

 

You've got to feel for shane. He's a top class fighter and always willing to fight anyone at any time. Yet still gets no break.

He takes on a prime cotto and the most ducked fighter in his division. Goes and tries mayweather in his own ring and calls out pacman.

Bloke shows everything good about the sport with that kind of show.

 

He also cheated and took PEDs.

 

Moseley only good when fighting smaller opponent but when...

 

Just for beating Margarito?

 

he was not even on the list after the Mayorga fight, then jumped to number 3-5 on a lot of list.

 

Yes, Shane is number one P4P and has bigger balls then Floyd and Pac combined. He's also not a moaning crying pre-madonna attention ***** who makes negotiations impossible like Pac and May are these days.

 

He's also a scumbag cheater.

 

Oh, you're trolling. I get it. Carry on.

 

there should be no question that who the P4P is:

Koki Kameda

psych it's Manny Pacquiao until proven otherwise

 

Xylocaine is legal.