So how does Brook fare against the rest...

He would walk through Bradley.

 

Ha ha, Bradley is a fu¢king nightmare for many, including Brook! No love for melon-head!

 

Dont kid yourself on!
Canelo is no slouch, Mosely too.

 

Maidana has underrated technique, hell of a jab on him these days, and isn't as slow as some say, in fact his power shots come in with decent speed.

You say Brook handled pressure, power and aggression vs Porter but Porter used it poorly, Maidana since teaming up with Garcia is a smarter offensive fighter than he was before. Isn't the same fighter that fought khan and Devon, only looking for the overhand right.

I'm not saying brook can't win, Maidana is beatable as proven and i rate Brook highly but no way can you say Brook is guarantee win vs Maidana.

Back to the power?, only one time as Porter looked like a good puncher, vs a shot Paulie. Maidana is clearly the bigger puncher of the two, if you made a poll on any forum, the winner would be Maidana. Chino isn't the best finisher as proven in some of his fights but he has some serious clubbing power.

(oh and Maidana is the heavier guy, 165 vs Floyd, compared to 158 for Porter vs Brook, taller as well)

I'll leave it with this, its all about opinions so i have no problem with you thinking brook wins easily (Boring if everybody agreed), maybe he would ha, but its a fight i would like to see. Loads of good fights to be made at WW.

 

Canelo has the workrate of an 80 year old emphysema sufferer ,Mosley was well past his prime too

Judah is the last fast guy he has faced

 

:good:This is a response people, regards to shenmue

 

Didn't you predict Porter would smash Brook?

 

BOLLOCKS, simple as that!

 

You lot are getting caught up in the hype, Brook done well but he spoiled alot of the fight and Porter tired badly.


Floyd & PAC, humilate brook simple.Pac has him ko'd and Floyd wouldn't let Brook win a round

Bradley would be a nightmare for Brook, he is quick & clever.

Maidana wouldn't tired like Porter and would Bully Brook like Porter did to he tired.

 

So Pacquiao should have wrapped it in .... ?

 

didnt you pick groves

 

Brook would outbox Maidana easily.

Bradley likely beats him.

 

Maidana experience beats Brook.

 

Bradley is very fast and awkward, good mover and good footwork and I think their reach is the same, it wouldn't be a case of "walking through him", it would be walking through a flurry of fast shots or a fast jab, catching him and then landing cleanly. Bradley is a tough opponent, perhaps underrated because of a lack of power, and Brook needs a few more good fights before he's ready for Bradley.

 

timing him. lets see if can do that. bradley is quick and very fit.