Lots of good matchups, for sure. I'd have to go with Cotto to win this one though. I think he frustrated and beat Mosley pretty decisively. The only reason it was close was because Cotto took a couple of rounds off and tried to box going backwards. They'd all be tough but PBF would be his toughest stylistic matchup. But PBF can't take the calculated pressure laid on by Cotto.
Roun-Robin. Juan Manuel Marquez vs. Floyd Mayweather jr Lt/ko9/ Manny Pacquiao D/Shane Mosley L 4-8/ Miguel Cotto W 8-4/ Timothy Bradley W 9-3 = 2(0)-2(1)-1 Floyd Mayweather jr vs. Juan Manuel Marquez Wtko9/ Manny Pacquiao Wt/ko10/ Shane Mosley W 8-4/ Miguel Cotto Wt/ko8/ Timothy Bradley Wt/ko7 = 5(4)-0-0 Manny Pacquiao vs. Juan Manuel Marquez D/ Floyd Mayweather jr Lt/ko10/ Shane Mosley L 5-7/ Miguel Cotto Wt/ko11/ Timothy Bradley Wt/ko4/ = 2(2)-2(1)-1 Shane Mosley vs. Juan Manuel Marquez W 8-4/ Floyd Mayweather jr L 4-8/ Manny Pacquiao W 7-5/ Miguel Cotto W 8-4/ Timothy Bradley W t/ko 9/ = 4(1)-1-0 Miguel Cotto vs. Juan Manuel Marquez L 4-8/ Floyd Mayweather jr Lt/ko8/Manny Pacquiao Lt/ko11/ Shane Mosley L 4-8/ Timothy Bradley W 8-4/ = 1(0)-4(2) Timothy Bradley vs. Juan Manuel Marquez L 3-9/ Floyd Mayweather jr Lt/ko7/Manny Pacquiao Lt/ko4/ Shane Mosley Lt/ko9/ Miguel Cotto L 4-8/ = 0-5(3)-0 Finals. 1.Floyd Mayweather jr vs. 2.Shane Mosley Mayweather 7 rounds Mosley 5 rounds Floyd Mayweather jr sweeps the round robin and beats Mosley a second time to clame this tourment. Whichnif real would be better than the 168 one.
Forget this catchweight trash.... if they were to have a super six, it needs to be at 140 or 147.....
Cotto, all this talk about his fights not being world class is Bull****. and off night? No, you have to be pretty ignorant to believe that. You have 12 rounds to adjust, don't pull none of that bull.
Bradley is an excellent boxer but has no business in this theoretical tournament. He does not have the power. He's not going to be effective against real WW's. Cotto (post-margarito) is not going to make it through this tournament without getting knocked out. Pacquiao might beat Bradley, JMM, or Cotto, JMM might beat Pacquiao, Cotto, or Bradley as well. We need to see how JMM looks at 144 to have a good basis to project his chances. Shane Mosley would probably get through everyone and fight Floyd in the final, with Floyd winning a competitive decision. Cotto maybe finishes 3rd by beating all the smaller opponents. He doesn't beat Mosley in a rematch. Floyd wins, Shane finishes 2nd.