Super Middleweight P4P Top 20, Opinions?

You're missing guys like Allan Green who isn't the best SMW out there but still a top 20 imo, at least until we see how he fairs against Adonis Stevenson,or like Renan St Juste, Brian Magee (WBA Interim Champ), James Degale.
What do you think of Dominic Wade and Anthony Dirrell

 

Boxing is a "what have you done for me lately?" sport.

Green has lost twice, and then beaten a guy who was 7-4. If he beats Demers (who I'm not sure even belongs in the top 20 himself, and at the back end if so) maybe he squeaks back into the rankings.

St. Juste impressed against Demers but had just lost before that. And it was only freaking Demers. :yep

Magee...*sigh*. I love Magee, but don't know that he belongs much higher than 15 or 16 at this stage of his career. Yeah, he has a belt and yeah he gave Bute a slight headache for a couple of rounds - but... Did you see that fight where he won his "championship"? Did you see who he beat? Awful, a farce.

DeGale lost legitimately to Groves, and then struggled with Wilk (looking like he might get KO'ed at times). He may be Euro champ but in my mind he's barely graduated from UK domestic level. I think a Kenny Anderson might even beat him.

Wade is unproven. His best win is Lowry, who he caught cold with a body shot. I suppose Estrada is no more proven, but I've seen a lot more of him and see the promise there. Wade has convincing to do..

Dirrell has just been out too long. Once Dr. Shaw Hi clears him, we'll see if he's still top 10 (should definitely be top 20). Maybe even near the top 5. I don't much like the guy, but as stated previously it's a weak division outside the elite and he's borderline elite at 168.

 

I got fights messed up. Green is fighting Demers and Pryor jr is fighting Stevenson. :O

 

Yeah I saw Jamie Barbosa with the unique stance. But that trinket of his, should put him in top 20.

 

:yep None of those four are top ten material (even though the elite end of the pool is shallow, maybe five deep)

The winners could meet and even the winner of that match would be at least a dozen pegs back.

 

I was referring to ANTHONY Dirrell.

Estrada as well as Wade and Periban and Maderna didn't really fought anybody, that's why I asked you what do you think about them and even I haven't put them in my top 20 with the exception of Maderna who beat Acosta, he will have an easy fight next so...
I want them to step up.
Shawn Estrada - I hope he takes a decent opponent next he's the most promising out of these 4.

 

atsch I misread.

Yeah, The Dog is exciting. He's ready to step up soon.

All those guys probably are.

It would be great if some of the young unbeaten guys were matched up against each other, but that isn't likely in this day and age where most talents get so protected and strung along.