sure shot HOF's

What advantage? Let's see the evidence. Show me a fight where the result would have been different because of roids - I mean concrete PROOF, not speculation. There's no way to prove it, therefore it shouldn't even factor in to HOF calculations.

 

Mayorga anybody?

 

Ignorance, a powerful thing. :nono

 

...................:-( idiot

 

casamayour over calzaghe and toney:nut. The thing is i have to do some more reaserch on toneys use of steroids. I guess seeing as you have mosley as a shoe in, toney just hasnt had a good enough career??nuthuh:huh:huh:huh:bart

 

In a more strict hall of fame Vargas probably wouldn't get in... but go checkout some of the names in the Boxing Hall of Fame. You'll see that all you really have to be is a name fighter in your generation to be inducted. Wouldn't surprise me at all if someone like Micky Ward got in as well... the standards are just that low.

 

after the leonard era

Whitaker
Chavez
Jones
Lewis
Holyfield
Hopkins
Pacquiao
Mayweather
Lopez
De La Hoya
Trinidad
Mosley
Nelson
Morales
Barrera
Calzaghe
Tyson
JM Marquez
McCallum
Galaxy
Toney
Fenech
Tszyu
Wright
Tapia
Carbajal
Camacho
Vitalai K
Wladimir K
Alvarez
Eubank
Michalczewski
Vazquez
R. Marquez
Gonzales
Canizales
Mitchell
Zaragoza
Norris
Castillo
Casamayor
Corrales

80% Chance
Benn
Hamed
J. Jackson
McClellan
Chang
Bowe
Zapata

50-50 Chance
Gatti
Haye
Otkke
Cotto
Campbell
Darchinyan
Hatton
Tarver
G. Johnson
Calderon
Vargas
Rosario
M. Taylor
Quartey
Medina
Montiel

 

This list is way way way too permissive. There are a lot of guys on this list that have been eligible for years and still haven't gotten in, including everyone on the 80% list.

 

^^^that's why i put them in the 80% bracket

they have already been snob so they have no guarantee that they can make it...

it just pisses to see norris and mitchell made it while leaving the likes of jackson, benn and mcclellan


who do you think from the 100% bracket should be downgraded?

 

actually, a lot of fighters can get in. the boxing HOF is not known for its high standards.

being considered as an ATG is a much bigger honor than being a HOFer.

 

i know ive missed out some names but at quick glance nigel benn should be a shoe in.

 

he cant be a shoo-in...he has already been nominated but was snob twice already

 

naz?

 

I think you forgot floyd lols

 

Absolutely - at the very least Benn should be there over Mitchell. Off your list, I'd downgrade Tszyu (50%), Vitali (50%), Wladimir (80%), Eubank (I wouldn't have him up there at all frankly - he's more like hall of very good), Vasquez (80%), R. Marquez (50%), J. Marquez (80%), Castillo (80%), Casamayor (50%) and Corrales (50%). Obviously the 50/50 list could be much longer as well, especially in respect of some of the 80's Koreans who haven't been recognized at all yet but there's been a movement to get them in. I would hope that Bowe doesn't have an 80% chance of getting in, but sadly he probably will based on his name and a couple of big wins. Moorer is another one you didn't mention that probably is around 80%.

Michalczweski is a good one that all of us missed. He's a lock.

Virgil Hill is another one that all of us have missed, who probably goes in the 50% category at least.