Teddy Atlas's 10 Greatest Heavyweights of All Time.

48 minutes?

Can't you summarize it for us real quick so we can jump right into calling Teddy Atlas and idiot and a parasite?

 

I agree with his #1 and #2.

 

Here is Teddy's list:

1. Louis
2. Ali
3. Johnson
4. Marciano
5. Foreman
6. Tunney
7. Dempsey
8. Holmes
9. Lewis
10. Liston

I am not sitting through a 48 minute Teddy video. Too much yelling and rambling. But he is interesting to listen to in small doses. I am subscribed to his youtube channel but i only listen to it in short doses.

Interesting list. I don't have a major problem with it even though my list is drastically different.

I don't quite understand the criteria. How can Teddy judge Jack Johnson's skills with the poor quality of film available?

Tunney had less than 10 fights at heavyweight and only 2 vs an elite opponent (Dempsey), who was past his prime. I think Tunney is great at 175 lbs but he doesn't have enough fights at heavyweight to merit that.

Marciano at #4 and Frazier not in the top 10 is also puzzling since they were similar in ability. If Marciano had 5 fights vs Ali and Foreman, there is a good chance he would go 1-4 like Frazier did.

It seems like Teddy ranks historical importance as an important criteria which partially explains Johnson, Tunney and Dempsey.

I don't have a major issue with it since part of why lists are interesting is because everyone has a different opinion. So while my list will be drastically different, i completely get that different people have different ideas. And i am happy as long as people remain passionate about boxing history regardless of how different their list is from mine.

 

Tunney was 19-0 in fights contested over 180lbs and, iirc, won 6 fights vs top 10 ranked HWs. I agree he has no place in an all time top 10 HW list.

 

Tunney over Lennox Lewis....?

 

Holyfield is missing.

 

speaking of boxing historians, i would love to see Monte Cox's updated list. Monte was a good poster and an excellent writer. Its a pity that saga with Revolver annoyed Monte to the point that he stopped posting and doesn't seem to have resumed since.

 

Oh i see. I got the list from 47 minutes and 38 seconds in the video so i thought he had Liston in there.

Yes if you are looking at historical significance, i can totally see Johnson and Dempsey so high.

 

I can get behind that list except for Tunney.