Last time this discussion came up, I said: Based on KO percentage: Gennady Golovkin 27 fights /24 KOs= 88% Gerald McClellan has an 85%KO ratio. 29KOs /34 fights Julian Jackson 49 knockouts / 61 fights = 80% KO John Mugabi was up at about 78% = 39KOs /50 fights. Marvin Hagler had 78% = 52KOs /67 fights Stanley Ketchel had 75%= 64 fights 48 KOs. Rocky Graziano 77 fights /52 KOs= 62% Carlos Monzon 100 fights/ 59 KOs= 59% It doesn't tell the whole story such as skill or opposition, but it gives you an idea. There are also some middleweights that grew out of the division and wound up fighting as light-heavyweights like Archie Moore. Middleweights who stayed at Middleweight Eduardo Lausse 87/63KOs=72% Eugene Hart 41/28KOs=68% Florentino Fernandez 67/43KOs=64% Charles Kid McCoy 116/65=56% Bennie Briscoe 96/53KOs=55% Tony Zale 87/45=52% Charley Burley 98/50=51% Al Hostak 84/41KOs=49% Freddie Steele 142/60KOs=42% Middleweights who moved up to heavyweight Archie Moore 219/131KOs=60% Bob Fitzsimmons 99/59KOs=60% Sam Langford 317/128KOs=40% Mickey Walker 164/60=36%
My intuition tells me that Golovkin, wherever he hits you, has unearthly damaging punches, maybe comparable to old Fitz in his ability to place his punches to any part of the body, and hurt you terribly...Of course he has not fought anyone of note to guage him with the alltime punchers, but====?.
Poor old Mr Bamford had stiff thumbs, a result of them having been broken in the cotton mills of Lancashire, he used to bite them through his gloves to loosen them .Reg Gitteridge has a nice line in his book ,"The Big Punchers", " Jock McAvoy was the only fighter who regularly bit the hand that fed him". So badly were Jock's hands damaged he had painkilling injections before fights.
So your just going off percentage? Then Ketchel at 75% KO ratio isnt as hard a puncher.. KO ratio dosent translate exactly to amount of power
No it doesnt, but Hagler' stats indicate he hit hard. Hostak for example has less than 50%ko's, no one denies he was a hard puncher. Now stop being pedantically silly.:nono
I've never thought of Walker as being an especially hard puncher, but he put a lot of lesser guys away.
He didnt show it so much in the lower weights, but it is very impressive how he battered light heavyweights and heavyweights. Today he would have stopped Paulino Uzcdun on cuts!
No order. Can't limit myself to 5! Ketchel Steele Hostak Chip (people forget what a brutal puncher he was) Robinson Fitzsimmons Krieger Apostoli Graziano Jackson McClellan
I was a Hagler fan and I have to agree. He definitely wasn't nor should he ever be considered one of the big punchers of MW history. Hags relied on timing to land his sharp, energy-zapping counter punches. Those coupled with his debilitating body attack were what accounted for all those KOs. I can't recall anyone he ever fought referring to him as the hardest puncher they ever faced either. A second-tier puncher, along with the likes of Monzon.
He's just one of the names I put out ,you don't have to agree with them ,the idea is to make up your own list.
I know just saying he shouldnt be on a hardest punchers list, he hit hard but not that hard. Hagler was more an effective puncher. ---- Jackson Fitzsimmons Ketchel Hostak Steele