The 50 greatest fighters ever! Revised

What about Terry Mcgovern?

 

Barbadoes Joe cracks my top 20.

 

I actually feel your list isn't bad....a few changes but still a good list bro.

 

I dont entirely agree with all of them, but no ADDIE just fine you tend to underrated Modern day greats. Fedor has a good perspective on them.

 

Although i think he rates Fitz to low i dont think its a joke to have Holy And Chavez high in fact id put them higher.

 

I have read good arguments by those who think he should be in the top 3.:yep

 

You my friend obviously forgot 3 Cuban legends...

You left out Cuban legends, Kid Chocolate, Kid Gavilan, Luis Manuel Rodriguez...

Do you know this boxers or you just left them out on purpose ??? ... :huh

Anyone that does not know this Hall of Fame greats does'nt deserve to be a boxing fan... :-(

 

To be honest- I am surprised we don't have more people hollering that Pacquiao is 10+ spots ahead of mayweather-

But Resume for Resume- I like this and your others a lot.

Quick Q- if a fighter beats another one currently, do they replace them? Or do you go stricktly by who beat who?

 

My point wasn't that the placings of Holyfield and Chavez were horribly wrong (though I do think Holyfield is unjustifiably high at #24), my point was that it is horribly wrong to have Holyfield and Chavez so far ahead of two vastly superior fighters in Fitzsimmons and McLarnin.

 

I dont put Mclarnin above Chavez :nono Or even Fitz but you could make a case for Fitz. Holyfield is probably place right i only have him a couple spots higher i have Chavez much higher.

 

Then I don't think I can help you. :-(

 

Good cause im tired of laying Chavez resume down and proving how much greater he was than people think.
One other thing i dont need no help! Im highly confident in my knowledge of the Sweet Science from 1800s to present:bart