The best RESUME at SMW

Probably Kessler still. Bute and Froch are close, but I give the slight edge to Bute.

 

Andrade:

-Kessler
-Bute(twice)
-Stieglitz
-Tsypko
-Mack
-

 

I agree

 

Froch.

 

Carl Froch.

 

In terms of wins? If so then even though i hate the guy Froch is tie with Ward and Kessler. Bute only win that is good is against Andrade who Kessler already easily beat.

 

Froch ..hes actually beaten a elite fighter in knocking out Jermain Taylor...Kessler has yet to beat any elite fighters

 

I'd go with Froch. He's got Jean Pascal, Jermain Taylor and Andre Dirrell.

 

:deal

Nor Pascal...so best win is Dirrell and this was ugly.

 

Froch easily. Pascal, Taylor and Dirrell. Anyone who claims otherwise is a tool.

 

Froch's had a better three-man run than anybody, and you can certainly make the case that that run elevates him above the field, but if you strip those three away or even tack them on the rest of his wins, the overall resume isn't clearly better than anyone's. Three stellar wins and a bunch of trifling ones aren't clearly better than many, many solid (well above trifling, but far from stellar) wins.

If this is SMW resume only, Abraham doesn't even belong on the list yet. So far he's knocked out two broken middleweights at the weight. If it's career resume (disregarding weight), he goes a little higher but still isn't a #1 candidate.

 

to be clear i am no huge joe c fan. but since he is way better then any other name on anyone's listed resume, Kessler gets top ranking. Considering that it is close between him and Froch when comparing other opposition I give it to a guy with an ATG on his resume. Guess that makes me a tool.

Also wasn't positive if we were just simply ranking who they faced or also the outcome

 

Sorry, but since when did resumés include wins? That's like saying Marion Wilson has a great resumé just because he's fought Francois Botha, Tyrell Biggs, Andrew Golota x2, Vaughn Bean, Ray Mercer, Kirk Johnson, Shannon Briggs, Orlin Norris, Ike Ibeabuchi, Carl Williams, Greg Page, Oleg Maskaev, Larry Donald, Hasim Rahman, Tony Thompson, Samuel Peter, Oliver McCall x2 and Chazz Witherspoon.