The better resume: PBF or JMM?

But at the same time, those fights could have gone either way. It's not as if they were clear to Pacquiao the way Mosley 1, B-Hop, or PBF were to Oscar.

And there are instances where we, as fans, SHOULDN'T go by the record book. Whitaker-Chavez, Whitaker-Ramirez, Lewis-Holt 1, etc...

That said, Mayweather's resume is CLEARLY better than Marquez's.

 

both are good but ill go for marquez on this one..

 

its not about who you fought, its what have you done for me lately.

Marquez obviously started his career slowly. he's the most ducked person for obvious reasons.

Floyd went on cruise control since he moved to bigger weight division. I can't blame him though its the logical thing when you make it big time.

 

Looking at names alone, Marquez.

Looking at victories/losses, Floyd.

Looking at the fights themselves, Floyd got a lucky escape against the prime Castillo and didn't look all that convincing against Judah and DLH, and JMM also had close shaves against Barrera, Diaz and Casamayor. About even there.

PBF's only victory against a good, prime opponent was probably Hatton and perhaps Castillo II. JMM's is probably Diaz, and the Pacquiao fights if you think he deserved them.

It's a close one.

 

Floyd all the way

 

floyd.

 

clearly,barrera is past his prime by the time jmm fought him.
marquez never fought morales...

 

Question!

Who would you say have the better resume of these two imaginary boxers?:

NUMBER 1
Norwood
Peden
Medina
Gainer
Pac
Polo
John
Barrera
Juarez
Casamayor
Diaz

NUMBER 2
Torres
J. Witter
Tszyu
Corley
Clottey
Cotto
PBF
Baldomir
Green
M. Ward
C. Spinks
Vasquez

Who has the better resume? Vote now!

 

of course jmm have a better resume than zab judah.

 

floyd by a mile. JMM hasnt beaten a great
fighter in his prime..

 

Nearly chopped Cotto in half??? Hold on , hold on for a sec there, are we talking about the same guy Cotto KO'd in the 5th rd.?

 

The point is...

If you just go by who they MET and not by who they BEAT...

then comparing resumes makes absolutely NO sense. And yes, based purely on opponents, Zab has the BETTER RESUME. Does he really have the best resume if comparing who they BEAT? No of course not.

 

HMMMMMMMMMMMM............... not many latinos in Montreal, I guess , right Joey????

 

Nope, regardless of the closeness of those fights, resume is who you fought, not beat.

 

hmmmmm sounds like someone's never been to montreal