THE BIG VOTE! Who deserves 10th position in The Ring's Pound-for-Pound rankings?

No. Donaire has done little since that fight (not his fault) whilst Vic has redeemed himself with wins over Kirilov (light puncher but good fighter and champion) and a win over Mijares (no.6 on my P4P rankings at that time)

All Donaire would need to do is beat another World-class fighter, coupled with his (fairly recent still) win over Vic I'd have no trouble placing him in the top 10. But the P4P top 10 is done on recent form and consistency, and Donaire hasn't really done anything since Vic (as I say, ithat's more of a promotional issue)

 

Can't have any fighters in the top 10 that are in possession of a Glass Jaw

 

hmmmm...?

 

john duddy

proof that undefeated means nothing.....

 

I'm having trouble picking between Vic and P.Williams.

 

Im going to be really stupid and say Vitali Klitschko, I know its crazy but when you think of it, hes only lost 2 fights both of them through injury, byrd he destroyed in a rematch after loosing the fight through a shoulder injury, and before the cut stop against lewis he was ahead on the cards. Hes knocked out pretty much every one he has got in the ring with. fair hes had a terrible division and not really beat any great fighters, but at the end of the day its hard for heavy weights and the whole pound for pound issue, they cant really move down weights to prove a point, seen as the heavywieght champ is suppose to be the pinicle of boxing, and he is by far the best, im going to be really crazy and say id put him 10th

 

There is so many disagrements regarding who is first or second or third...
Who's 10th?????????
zzzzzzzzzzzzzz.....

 

Really? Unlike the complete fantasy of Pound 4 Pound we actually get to see Glass Jaws get shattered all the time. And it happens in a Boxing ring where it actually matters not on a message board like Pound 4 Pound does.

Don't let me stop you from playing the Boxing version of Dungeons and Dragons though. :roflatsch

 

Chris John, though Marquez was robbed....he did still get the win

 

ya but the premise is the same; P4P rate skill/ability in the ring (which we get to see) and glass jaw rankings rate chin ability in the ring (which we get to see).

whos to say who has the worst chin really as not everyone gets hit by the same punches by the same people!

so enjoy your game of dungeons and dragons mate.....:hi:

 

I say Paul Williams at 9 and Juanma Lopez at 10. Hatton and Caballero should be replaced with these two.