THE BIG VOTE. Who has the best resume from 1990 til now?

PBF took a break from fighting top opposition in much the same way Roy did during the peak period of his career. After his lackluster performances against Castillo he moved on to fighting second rate fighters like N'Dou, Bruseles, Corley, Sosa, shot Gatti, etc.

Roy dominated through his entire career as well until age caught up with him. Floyd retired early so we never got to see what age did to him, therefore they're incomparable in that sense. Prime for prime, if you compare their list of opponents, Roy clearly holds the edge.

Floyd's performance against Chico was about on par with Roy's performance against Toney.

Hatton isn't even as good a win as Roy's over Ruiz, Tarver, Griffin, Hill, etc.

As for dominating everyone at 140, he had 3 fights there for ****'s sake against the same lackluster competition I just named.

Probably his shut-out win over top 2 P4P ranked James Toney. And Floyd has done what to compare?

 

That one fighter Floyd struggled with also happened to be the best fighter he'd ever faced. Against Roy's best opponents (both of which were at least a level above Castillo) he won in easy, dominating fashion.

Again, Roy and Floyd are incomparable in that Floyd retired early to avoid getting smoked in much the same way Roy did when past his prime. Moron.

 

Oddly enough I had him losing clearly to both Quartey and Whitaker. I thought the Mosley I fight was about as close as the Mayweather fight.

 

His last fight was against a world champion wasnt it? adn again look at the mans resume you cant stake anybodys up to that for real

Qawi
Dokes
Douglas
Foreman
Holmes
Moorer
Bowe
Tyson
Lewis
Ruiz
Byrd
Toney
Ibragimov
Mercer
Czyz
Parker
De Leon
These were all champions and I am sure i missed a few along the way

 

Mayweather should not be in the other category.

 

1)MAB-x2 Morales,Hamed and Mckinney.
2)ODlh- Quartey(very close though),Vargas. I'm convinced he thoroughly beat Tito and Mosely II.
3) Lewis- A whole raft of heavyweights at a very consistan level. Imho would've dealt with an intimidated looking Bowe had they ever met.
His loss against Rahman is the one thing that prevents me not having him at no.1.

 

PACFAN,

Dear *** Kind regards,

I brought up Czyz cus he is a former world champion, but I know you knew that right?
its not about wins, its about Resume, who has the most impressive resume isnt that what this thread is about, well Holyfield has it.
Yes Holyfield lost some fights but he lost to top fighters period.

 

Oscar de la Hoya has the best resume (not counting wins or loses, just resume): G. Hernandez, JCC, Whitaker, Trinidad, Quartey, Mosley, Vargas, Hopkins, Mayweather, soon Pacquiao, etc.

Who is the greatest fighter since 1990 (considering wins and loses)?

1. Jones: wins over Hopkins, Toney, Hill, Woods, Ruiz, Tarver, etc.
2. Hopkins: wins over Trinidad, Tarver, Wright, Pavlik, etc.
3. Mayweather: wins over De la Hoya, Hatton, JLC, G. Hernandez, Corrales, Judah, etc.
4. Lewis: wins over Holyfield, V. Klitschko, Rahman, Mercer, Golota, shot Tyson, etc.

 

no doubt roberto duran if your talking boxers that have been active since 1990