It's rare for me starting a thread, so its about time I started one. The question I ask everyone. The most impressive performance you have ever seen from a fighter in boxing history?. It doesn't need to be a fighter in his prime, and a popular choice that mostly everyone generally considers to be his best performance. You could weigh everything up, including the performance of the fighter you select combined with his age at the time. Example 1. The fighter you pick well be in his mid 30's at the time and years past his prime, and was also not in his prime weight, but he got the win over a younger opponent. Lets say Foreman's win over Moorer, or Duran's winning his last world title against Barkley. Example 2. It could well be the other way around, a younger fighter easily knocking out a fighter past his prime in devastating fashion. Hearns knocking out Duran?. You know what I mean guys. Just take everything into consideration. I want one fight from each poster. Even do a top 5 or 10. But lets have one that each poster considers "The greatest performance they have ever seen".
For me it's either Tyson vs Spinks or Hearns vs Duran. I don't think Duran or Spinks had any chance those nights.
Joe Louis vs. Max Baer - for me it has to be one of the best performances that Louis has ever done. If I were to sell Joe Louis that is the performance I'd use as a demo. Bernard Hopkins vs. Felix 'tito' Trinidad - BHop was in a zone. Mike Tyson vs. Donovan "Razor" Ruddock - Tyson was up against a fighter with a good chin and a very big punch. Round 6 Razor catches Mike with "The Smash" and follows up with a couple of big shots. Tyson after taking those heavy blows smiles and taps his chin asking for more. He subsequently stops him the very next round. Joe Frazier vs. Bob Foster - nobody is unbeatable, but if 20 years from now you were trying to make a case that Joe Frazier was unbeatable to a novice boxing fan, this is the video that I'd show him. Quarry II would also be a good choice he was without blemish in this fight.
Holyfield vs Bowe 1, that really showed Holyfields heart in all its glory. Sadly enough that was the last time we seen Bowe in his prime, wieght issues and problems with his wife took alot of prime away from Bowe. Its rare now adays to see 2 undefeated fighters who are both great fighters in there prime go at it, I guess that only happens once in a blue moon.
leonard over hagler norton over ali foreman over frazier foreman over lyle duran over leonard corrales over castillo
A 40-1 longshot winning just about every second of every round and doing it in dominating fashion against what alot of people were already thinking was the best fighter ever on the planet. I'm of the opinion that Douglas had the perfect height, reach, weight and style to dominate Tyson everytime. People like to say that Tyson was'nt in shape or motivated, but I've been a fan long enough to know that a fighter does'nt dominate another like that unless he's got his number. A truly great performance from James "Buster" Douglas. The knockdown Douglas suffered in the 8th is the only thing that keeps it from probably being the most perfect performance in boxing history!
Louis vs Schmeling II Tyson vs Berbick Ali vs Foreman Frazier vs Ali I Whitaker vs Chavez (robbery!) Liston vs Williams Lewis vs Golota Holyfield vs Tyson I Leonard vs Benitez
Do not get me wrong unlike one judge I had Douglas ahead going into the tenth and he was winning comfortable, but he did not dominate the fight like you suggest, but that also adds to the greatness of the win IMO. My answer would be Chavez/Rosario, the best one sided fight you could ever see. Second would be Duran/Palomino, boxings greatest living fighter putting together his finest performance.
In first place: Duran Leonard I (quality of opponent i.e P4P great in prime, plus jump in weight class) Not in any order, and in agreement with some of the earlier posters: Hearns Cuevas (silky smooth and utterly devastating) Hearns Duran (see above) Ali Williams (work of art, quantity of unanswered punches landed) Douglas Tyson (quality of opponent, seeing a gameplan through beautifully) Frazier Ali I (dogged determination, perhaps the only man capable of taking away Ali's unbeaten record) Duran DeJesus II (recovery from early knockdown, quality of opponent, speed, skill and endurance) SRL Hearns I (quality of opponent, display of genuine substance as well as style)