The Greatest Pound for Pound fighter of all time?

Yes they should. Your list is ****ed.

 

Sugar Ray Robinson. From waht I have seen i cannot think of anyone better.

 

that was good :good

 

Whitaker was placed as the 10th greatest fighter of the last 80 years by Ring magazine. Thats a generous placing, and can't argue with it myself.

I can't agree with him being #1.

 

confused or pissed

 

Willie quit in the ring and took a dive, breaking two of the cardinal sins of consideration for top spot, let alone his resume doesnt warrant a ranking in the top ten

 

If (a big if) you have Robinson at no.1 at WW then you would have Robinson as your top fighter in two of the original 8 divisions and only ranked 4th. Out of curiosity where do you rank the fighters above Robinson in there respective divisions

 

Willie Pep, the second greatest defensive fighter that ever lived.

 

I have a phobia of lists. The thought of trying to justify in my own mind why one fighter is higher than another just pisses me off, like for example my top 175lb'er for H2H is Gene Tunney, but he wouldnt actually garner a place in my top 5 overall at 175.

It amazes me how people can construct top 100 lists (Tbooze, take a bow) when I'd struggle to come up with a top 5

 

interesting you didnt contend any of my points, which brings me to the question, why quote me?