I thought he might've. The first fight was close and hard to score IMO. The first time I saw it, I had Toney winning, but subsequent times watching it I haven't been too sure. Toney had the bigger and more eye-catching spurts, but McCallum outworked him in between. The second fight I thought was a clear win for McCallum. Blatant robbery. The third fight was a clear win for Toney.
I thought both looked excellent, actually. McCallum simply was so effective with that right hand to the body. I recently watched the rematch, and while i didn't score it, i think McCallum took it by a point or so. Sweet_Scientist's scorecard looks a lot like how i remember it.
i think i have the same as SS ill check later my exact score card i loved fights 1 and 2 thought they was excellant, the 3rd was when they was passed it so it was shite