The Official Running Tally of Blatant Robberies & Dodgy Decisions Thread.

Dave Allen was robbed against Johnny Fisher.

He served as a sacrificial lamb, taking the robbery bullet so Usyk didn't have to. Shame about the result, but the real boxing fans know who won that fight. Godspeed, White Rhino.

 

Allen absolutely mugged there. Took years off Fishers career

 

Israel Mercado was robbed blind of a decision win against Leonardo Rubalcava. This was no Draw.

 

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/eduardo-amil-mancito-vs-jhon-damas-gemino-rbr.732746/

Idek what to say here. Mancito won nine of ten rounds on my card, only to lose a SD. Granted he did have three points taken for low blows - but one judge had it a shutout for Gemino (100-87), and I just can't wrap my head around that.

 

@Chuck Norris @CST80 @PinoyProdigy it's...bad.

 

03/01/2025 - Gervonta Davis vs. Lamont Roach - Majority Draw

Davis showed relief at a draw. That should tell the whole story.

Also if not for incompetent/corrupt reffing even this would have been a win. Tank took a ****ing knee in the middle of a round. I don't care what it was for. You do that, you should get an automatic 10-8.

Imagine if Floyd Mayweather had said to the ref "Nah I didn't get hurt by a punch, I just hurt my hand and need a break" and the ref was just like "Oh okay, well, just don't do it again ya little rascal!" That's basically what happened here.

It's too late for all the folks that bet on him to win, but Roach and his team really oughta try and get this result overturned. Doubt they could get it turned into anything more than an NC sadly, and it might be better if they leave it in that case. Least he can still be the first blemish on his record that way

 

I cannot fathom how Olascuaga was awarded the decision over Kyoguchi when he was getting backed up and outlanded nearly every round and looked clueless for the majority of the fight. The KD call in the 11th is pretty contentious too.

 

some to add here from a previous thread

 

Before it gets forgotten about:

22nd March 2025 Jasmine Artiga MD over Regina Chavez

As bad as it gets I thought: 10-0 Chavez was a viable card. Not the first time she's been heinously robbed either.

 

kambosos vs lee selby was that on your list?

 

05/10/25 - Emanuel Navarrete vs. Charly Suarez

Technical Decision for Navarrete after a "head clash" caused by Suarez's fist opened a cut over his eye, in a place that didn't obscure his vision too badly, which his cutmen were able to work ****ing miracles on until he began gassing, at which point suddenly the cutmen seemed to have zero mending abilities and he came out with no work done on it to begin round 8.

Also I gotta say, I ain't watched as much boxing as some of you folks, but this is the only time I've ever seen a man's cheek cut someone's forehead to a point it's open and gushing blood a second later

Suarez was robbed of a rightful TKO victory, and I'll argue that he was robbed of a proper KO victory had the fight been allowed to continue. But that's alright. There's already talks of a rematch, and if it happens I have no doubt Suarez rights the wrong

 

Dave Sutherland’s, ridiculous vote for Caleb Plant on Saturday, should be investigated!