The Official Running Tally of Blatant Robberies & Dodgy Decisions Thread.

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by CST80, Apr 5, 2023.



  1. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    That's an excellent idea, albeit a time consuming one. If you want to help out and flesh the thread out a little, by adding them. Be my guest. It would be more than welcome.
     
    Pepsi Dioxide likes this.
  2. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    He definitely deserves a special place on the list for British stoppages... that someone needs to do.:D
     
    caine and Wizbit1013 like this.
  3. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    The Robberies and Questionable Decisions of 2022.


    1/7/22 - Edwin De Los Santos vs. William Foster III - Foster SD
    1/29/22 - Ilunga Junior Makabu vs. Thabiso Mchunu II - Makabu SD
    2/5/22 - Samuel Antwi vs. Conah Walker - Antwi UD
    2/5/22 - Raymond Ford vs. Edward Vazquez - Ford SD
    2/5/22 - Ryan Karl vs. Omar Juarez - Juarez SD
    2/5/22 - Abel Ramos vs. Lucas Santamaria - Santamaria UD
    2/5/22 - Luis Nery vs. Carlos Castro - Nery SD
    2/6/22 - Rene Mark Cuarto vs. Pedro Taduran II - Cuarto TMD
    2/18/22 - Paul Kroll vs. Marquis Taylor - Split Draw
    2/26/22 - Josh Taylor vs. Jack Catterall - Taylor SD
    2/27/22 - Tibo Monabesa vs. Jayson Vayson - Monabesa MD (Changed to NC)
    2/27/22 - Lawrence Okolie vs. Michal Cieslak - Okolie UD
    3/4/22 - Gabriel Flores Jr. vs. Abraham Montoya - Flores Jr. MD
    3/11/22 - Gabriel Maestre vs. Taras Shelestyuk - Split Draw
    3/12/22 - Jezreel Corrales vs. Miguel Madueno - Corrales UD
    3/19/22 - Edgar Berlanga vs. Steve Rolls - Berlanga UD
    3/25/22 - Lukasz Stanioch vs. Hadillah Mohoumadi - Stanioch SD
    3/25/22 - Cesar Francis vs. Mohamed Mimoune - Francis UD
    3/26/22 - Maria Cecilia Roman vs. Ebanie Bridges - Bridges UD
    4/9/22 - Bryant Perrella vs. Kevin Salgado Zambrano - Split Draw
    4/26/22 - Vince Paras vs. Robert Paradero - Split Draw
    4/29/22 - Fedor Chudinov vs. Azizbek Abdugofurov - Abdugofurov UD
    4/30/22 - Katie Taylor vs. Amanda Serrano - Taylor SD
    5/7/22 - Ryan Rozicki vs. Yamil Alberto Peralta - Rozicki SD
    5/7/22 - Montana Love vs. Gabriel Gollaz Valenzuela - Love UD
    5/21/22 - Joshua Buatsi vs. Craig Richards - Buatsi UD
    6/4/22 - David Papot vs. Ahmed El Mousaoui - Papot SD
    6/7/22 - Takuma Inoue vs. Gakuya Furuhashi - Inoue UD
    6/11/22 - Ijaz Ahmed vs. Quaise Khademi ( III - Split Draw
    6/11/22 - Carlos Caraballo vs. Victor Santillan - Santillan UD
    6/11/22 - Edgar Berlanga vs. Roamer Alexis Angulo - Berlanga UD
    6/24/22 - Jonathan Gonzalez vs. Mark Anthony Barriga - Gonzalez UD
    6/29/22 - Liam Wilson vs. Matias Carlos Adrian Rueda - Wilson UD
    7/16/22 - Ricardo Rafael Sandoval vs. David Jimenez - Jimenez MD
    7/23/22 - Joet Gonzalez vs. Isaac Dogboe - Dogboe SD
    8/20/22 - Alberto Puello vs. Botirzhon Akhmedov - Puello SD
    8/20/22 - Lindolfo Delgado vs. Omar Aguilar - Delgado UD
    8/20/22 - Filip Hrgovic vs. Zhilei Zhang - Hrgovic UD
    8/27/22 - Jose Pedraza vs. Richard Commey - Split Draw
    8/27/22 - Ramon Averanga vs. Jose Velasquez II - Averanga SD
    9/2/22 - Kamil Sokolowski vs. Marcin Siwy - Spilt Draw
    9/3/22 - Juan Francisco Estrada vs. Argi Cortes - Estrada UD
    9/4/22 - Andy Ruiz Jr. vs. Luis Ortiz - Ruiz UD
    9/10/22 - Rostam Ibrahim vs. Chico Kwasi II - Ibrahim UD
    9/17/22 - Aaron Aponte vs. Fernando Angel Molina - Split Draw
    9/17/22 - Jesse Rodriguez vs. Israel Gonzalez - Rodriguez UD
    10/29/22 - Hector Valdez vs. Max Ornelas - Valdez SD
    11/1/22 - Shokichi Iwata vs. Jonathan Gonzalez - Gonzalez UD
    11/23/22 - Michael Zerafa vs. Danilo Creati - Zerafa UD
    11/26/22 - Dillian Whyte vs. Jermaine Franklin - Whyte MD
    11/26/22 - Yokasta Valle vs. Evelin Nazarena Bermudez - Valle MD
    12/2/22 - Brandon Glanton vs. David Light - Light SD
    12/3/22 - Julio Cesar Martinez vs. Samuel Carmona - Martinez MD
    12/10/22 - Teofimo Lopez vs. Sandor Martin - Lopez SD
    12/11/22 - Elnur Samedov vs. Moussa Gholam - Samedov SD
    12/17/22 - Souleymane Cissokho vs. Thulani Mbenge - Cissokho MD
    12/31/22 - Kazuto Ioka vs. Joshua Franco - Majority Draw
     
    Levook likes this.
  4. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    Another one just tonight, hot off the [presses.

    4/5/23 - Alexander Duran vs. Carlos Sanchez - Sanchez UD
     
  5. Levook

    Levook Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,113
    2,343
    Aug 26, 2020
    This is absolutely mind blowing! That looks like close to 60 fights so far just since last year. Absolutely unacceptable.

    I'm having a hard time getting my head around this. Surely this is just a phenomenon since last year? I can't ever remember thinking anything remotely close to that number of robberies/dodgy decisions in such a short span of time, never in all my years as a fan.
     
    CST80 likes this.
  6. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    No... sadly, it's par for the course. Since I joined Kirk's League back in 2014, it makes it much easier to keep track, since most of the matches are pretty obscure, this is a pretty common occurrence, with roughly this many robberies or questionable decisions yearly.:ohno
     
    Levook likes this.
  7. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    Robberies and Questionable Decisions of 2021

    1/2/21 - Roger Gutierrez vs Rene Alvarado II - Gutierrez UD
    1/23/21 - Sebastian Horacio Papeschi vs Marcelo Esteban Cóceres II - Papeschi SD
    2/13/21 - Zelfa Barrett vs. Kiko Martinez - Barrett UD
    2/17/21 - Janelson Figueroa Bocachica vs Mark Reyes Jr - Bocachica MD
    2/20/21 - Adrien Broner vs Jovanie Santiago - Broner UD
    2/20/21 - Fedor Chudinov vs. Isaac Chilemba - Split Draw
    2/24/21 - Sivenathi Nontshinga vs. Christian Araneta - Nontshinga UD
    2/27/21 - Pedro Taduran vs. Rene Mark Cuarto - Cuarto UD
    2/27/21 - Zhilei Zhang vs. Jerry Forrest II - Majority Draw
    2/27/21 - Ijaz Ahmed vs. Quaise Khademi - Ahmed MD
    3/13/21 - Juan Francisco Estrada vs Roman Gonzalez II - Estrada SD
    3/18/21 - Jose Martinez vs Israel Gonzalez - Majority Draw
    3/20/21 - Alex Martin vs. Luis Hernandez Ramos - Martin UD
    4/17/21 - Tony Harrison vs. Bryant Perrella - Split Draw
    4/24/21 - David Adeleye vs. Kamil Sokolowski - Adeleye PTS
    5/1/21 - Dereck Chisora vs. Joseph Parker I - Parker SD
    5/7/21 - Magomed Kurbanov vs. Liam Smith - Kurbanov UD
    5/29/21 - Jason Quigley vs. Shane Mosley Jr. - Quigley MD
    6/19/21 - Isaac Dogboe vs. Adam Lopez - Dogboe MD
    6/19/21 - Angelo Leo vs. Aaron Alameda - Leo MD
    6/19/21 - Ibeth Zamora vs Marlen Esparza - Esparza UD
    7/17/21 - Jermell Charlo vs. Brian Carlos Castano - Split Draw
    7/23/21 - Janelson Figueroa Bocachica vs Shinard Bunch - Split Draw
    8/7/21 - Gabriel Maestre vs Mykal Fox - Maestre UD
    8/14/21 - Joshua Franco vs. Andrew Moloney III - Franco UD
    8/14/21 - John Riel Casimero vs. Guillermo Rigondeaux - Casimero SD
    8/20/21 - Kali Reis vs. Diana Prazak - Reis MD
    8/28/21 - Ijaz Ahmed vs. Quaise Khademi - Split Draw
    8/28/21 - Akeem Ennis Brown vs Sam Maxwell - Maxwell UD
    9/1/21 - Kazuto Ioka vs Francisco Rodriguez Jr - Ioka UD
    9/4/21 - Ebanie Bridges vs Mailys Gangloff - Bridges PTS
    9/10/21 - Sam Eggington vs. Bilel Jkitou - Eggington SD
    9/10/21 - Oscar Valdez vs. Robson Conceicao - Valdez UD
    9/11/21 - Kerman Lejarraga vs. Dylan Charrat - Lejarraga TMD
    9/25/21 - Campbell Hatton vs. Sonni Martinez - Hatton PTS
    9/25/21 - Christopher Ousley vs Khasan Baysangurov - Ousley MD
    10/2/21 - Juan Hernan Leal vs. Christian Nicolas Andino - Leal MD
    10/2/21 - Lucas Brian Ariel Bastida vs. Juan Manuel Taborda - Split Draw
    10/9 /21- Robin Krasniqi vs. Dominic Boesel II - Boesel SD
    11/5/21 - Luis Melendez vs Thomas Mattice - Melendez UD
    11/19/21 - Kali Reis vs. Jessica Camara - Reis SD
    11/20/21 - Esquiva Falcao vs. Patrice Volny - Falcao TSD
    11/20/21 - Isaac Dogboe vs. Christopher Diaz - Dogboe MD
    11/27/21 - Stephen Fulton vs. Brandon Figueroa - Fulton MD
    11/27/21 - Gary Antonio Russell vs. Alexandro Santiago - Russell MD
    12/2/21 - Michael Hunter vs. Jerry Forrest - Split Draw
    12/5/21 - Sergiy Derevyanchenko vs. Carlos Adames - Adames MD
    12/5/21- Sebastian Fundora vs. Sergio Garcia - Fundora UD
    12/5/21 - Gervonta Davis vs. Isaac Cruz - Davis UD
    12/31/21 - Kazuto Ioka vs. Ryoji Fukunaga - Ioka UD
     
    Levook likes this.
  8. WhataRock

    WhataRock VIP Member Full Member

    32,561
    13,989
    Jul 29, 2004
    This thread needs to be forwarded to the proper authorities.
     
    Levook and CST80 like this.
  9. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    Robberies and Questionable Decisions of 2021


    1/18/20 - Sebastian Formella vs. Roberto Arriaza - Formella UD
    1/25/20 - Caleb Truax vs. David David Basajjamivule - Truax MD
    1/31/20 - Ilunga Makabu vs. Michał Cieślak - Makabu UD
    2/1/20 - Pedro Taduran vs Daniel Valladares - Technical Draw
    2/6/20 - Óscar Negrete vs. Alberto Ezequiel Melián - Negrete UD
    2/8/20 - Gary Russell Jr. vs. Tugstsogt Nyambayar - Russell UD
    2/21/20 - Mohamed Mimoune vs. Tyrone McKenna - McKenna UD
    2/22/20 - Sebastian Fundora vs. Daniel Lewis - Fundora UD
    2/29/20 - Mikey Garcia vs. Jessie Vargas - Garcia UD
    3/6/20 - Aliu Bamidele Lasisi vs. Norbelto Jimenez - Split Draw
    3/7/20 - Artur Szpilka vs. Serhiy Radchenko - Szpilka MD
    6/16/20 - Giovani Santillan vs. Antonio DeMarco - Santillan MD
    8/15/20 - Rolando Romero vs. Jackson Marinez - Romero UD
    8/1/20 - Ted Cheeseman vs. Sam Eggington - Cheeseman UD
    8/12/20 - Maxi Hughes vs. Jono Carroll - Hughes UD
    8/28/30 - Jack Culcay vs. Abass Baraou - Culcay SD
    8/29/20 - Jose Carlos Ramirez vs. Viktor Postol - Ramirez MD
    9/12/20 - Mark Heffron vs. Denzel Bentley I - Draw
    9/26/20 - Luis Nery vs. Aaron Alameda - Nery UD
    9/26/20 - Jermall Charlo vs. Sergiy Derevyanchenko - Charlo UD
    9/26/20 - Daniel Roman vs Juan Carlos Payano - Roman UD
    9/30/20 - Ohara Davies vs. Tyrone McKenna - Davies MD
    10/9/20 - Emanuel Navarrete vs. Ruben Villa - Navarrete UD
    10/17/20 - Quinton Randall vs. Jan Carlos Rivera - Randall UD
    10/17/20 - Thomas Patrick Ward vs. Thomas Essomba - Technical Split Draw
    10/17/20 - Vasyl Lomachenko vs. Teofimo Lopez - Lopez UD
    10/17/20 - Lewis Ritson vs. Miguel Vazquez - Ritson SD
    10/24/20 - Sergey Lipinets vs. Custio Clayton - Majority Draw
    11/14/20 - Joshua Franco vs. Andrew Moloney II - NC (Moloney robbed of clear TKO)
    11/23/20 - Sho Ishida vs. Toshiya Ishii - Ishida UD
    11/27/20 - Emmanuel Tagoe vs. Mason Menard - Tagoe MD
    11/27/20 - Daniel Jacobs vs. Gabriel Rosado - Jacobs SD
    12/5/20 - Lyndon Arthur vs. Anthony Yarde - Arthur SD
    12/12/20 - Florian Marku vs. Jamie Stewart - PTS Draw
    12/19/20 - Emmanuel Rodríguez vs. Reymart Gaballo - Gaballo SD
    12/19/20 - Gary Antonio Russell vs Juan Carlos Payano - Russell TUD
    12/26/20 - Masayuki Ito vs. Hironori Mishiro - Mishiro MD
     
  10. FastSmith7

    FastSmith7 Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,958
    8,646
    Sep 16, 2017
    Where do you rank this in your all time robbery list? This was probably the worst I've ever seen, I had it 6-0
     
    TheShellofKell and NullaLexInk like this.
  11. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    You'd be surprised at how many 6 and 8 round matches, are damned near shutouts were one of the participants get robbed blind. So it probably wouldn't rank all that highly. The 10 and 12 rounders usually always take top honors, because the absolute audacity to takes to rob someone like John Ryder, who arguably won 10 out of 12 rounds against Smith, that's ****ing bold.
     
  12. NullaLexInk

    NullaLexInk Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,895
    3,075
    Mar 10, 2022
    I'm not sure it qualifies as a robbery, but Badou Jack vs. Richard Rivera was sketchy as ****. One round went on a whole minute longer than it should have.
     
    gollumsluvslave likes this.
  13. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    Jesus Christ, this thread is on and popping already. Yet another one tonight, 2 so far this week alone.

    4/6/23 - Angel Acosta vs. Angelino Cordova - Cordova UD
     
    Pepsi Dioxide likes this.
  14. sasto

    sasto Boxing Junkie Full Member

    12,067
    15,541
    Aug 5, 2020
    Funny enough almost all the 2022 robberies helped me in the league, less than half have this year so far.

    I think now that I recognize more names I'm not checking where the fight is happening before I pick.
     
    CST80 and JunlongXiFan like this.
  15. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    221,002
    195,073
    Nov 23, 2013
    Yeah, well most of them have been to my detriment. Which is a common theme for me. I see the possible most think impossible, most of the time hoping for at least two honest judges.... and pay for it time and time again. I'm roughly 20 wins behind in the league. Let's see....

    1/25/23 - Wulan Tuolehazi vs. Sho Kimura - Majority Draw I picked Kimura
    1/28/23 - Artem Dalakian vs. David Jimenez - Dalakian UD I picked Jimenez
    2/17/23 - Ardreal Holmes vs. Ismael Villarreal - Holmes SD I picked Villareal
    2/23/23 - Manuel Flores vs. Franklin Gonzalez - Flores SD I picked Gonzalez
    3/12/23 - Koen Mazoudier vs. Ben Mahoney - Split Draw I picked Mahoney
    3/17/23 - Ijaz Ahmed vs. Marcel Braithwaite - Split Draw I picked Ahmed
    3/18/23 - Kureysh Sagov vs. Ali Baloyev II - Majority Draw I picked Baloyev
    3/24/23 - Conah Walker vs. Kane Gardner - Gardner PTS I picked Walker
    3/25/23 - Michael Gomez Jnr vs. Levi Giles - Gomez SD I picked Giles
    3/25/23 - Chris Colbert vs. Jose Valenzuela - Colbert UD I picked Valenzuela
    4/1/23 - Roy Jones Jr. vs. Anthony Pettis - Pettis MD I picked Roy

    Well....that halves my deficit right there.:hang



    I initially picked Diallo, but fearing a robbery, I switched to Zinad.
    3/11/23 - Malik Zinad vs. Mickael Diallo - Zinad UD
     
    sasto likes this.