The Post Pacquiao-Mayweather Precipitous Decline Of The Welterweight Division Is Near

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by CST80, Aug 6, 2015.


  1. CST80

    CST80 De Omnibus Dubitandum Staff Member

    238,344
    229,037
    Nov 23, 2013
    I know this won't be a very popular opinion, but when have I ever let that stop me from posting something.

    The Welterweight Division is on the verge of being in shambles, and it will completely fall apart the moment Mayweather and Pacquiao finally retire, and that moment is drawing near. Soon it will be at hand and what will we be left with........Let's take a look shall we?

    The Post Pacweather Era will look something like this.

    Kell Brook-Probably the best in the division after the two current top dogs, but where will he go beyond getting his Khan match that he so desires and an eventual clash with fellow alpha welter Thurman. What exciting matches involving Special K can be made that will draw real interest from the audience?

    Keith Thurman-Incredibly skilled counter puncher whose power while decent, like most has seemingly faded now that he's stepped up his opposition, he's very good and a hell of an all around talent...but that chin (and body) of his worries me, he's been stunned by Chaves, Diaz, Soto-Karass, Guerrero and now of all people Collazo, this doesn't bode well for his future against even bigger punchers like Brook or even Porter.

    Terence Crawford-I really like Crawford he's a good guy and awesome for Boxing in Omaha the crowds are amazing there...now what happens when he leaves Omaha....crickets. The Gamboa match was thrilling..because Gamboa fought like an idiot and went all out. The rest of his matches are enough to put someone to sleep. Beltran was a snoozefest, Sanabria was mindnumbing, Klimov make me want to hang myself, Burns was dull and Dulorme aside from the great finish was Boxing's version of Nyquil. He may end up dominating the division for the foreseeable future which will make people not want to see it very much. Pernell Whitaker was an all time great defensive fighter no doubt, but no one wanted to watch him either.

    Amir Khan-Is one somewhat decent to average puncher away from being shot right back down the rankings by brutal KO, most likely at the hands of Kell Brook next year, Khan is vastly overrated and not even fun to watch anymore, and hopefully him getting beaten up by a feather fist like Algieri will wake some people up to his obvious limitations, he's not likeable enough to market to most fans outside of England either.

    Errol Spence Jr.-Far too soon to declare him the second coming of Mayweather, who has he beaten of any note? Phil Lo Greco, Samuel Vargas and Emmanuel Lartey..So What. Lo Greco was a decent scalp but he'd only fought once in the last year and a half and was brought in as a last minute replacement. Spence has got the skills, but his chin hasn't been tested nor has he been in with anyone who could truly test him. And one other thing his personality is dreadfully dull, so I don't think he has much of a chance at crossover Mayweather like ****talking success.

    Sadam Ali-He's average at best and will most likely falter the moment he steps up, Abregu is shopworn and had been largely inactive for the year before and was dropped in his previous match, and add to that he was dropped by Tim Bradley...so that Ali KO seems a hell of a lot less impressive, but Abregu exposed Dulorme...who as it turns out, kind of sucks anyway. Ali looked average against Santana and didn't have the power to stop him and Karim Mayfield stopped him. He looked bad against Jeremy Bryan and finally dropped him in the last round which evened the fight up, and that was after Amir Imam stopped in 2. He style is dull and won't win fans over.

    Amir Imam-Very talented as well and will surely make his way north soon, but he may be packing glass, he was put down by Maldonado Jr., but he came back with a KO victory over him and his highlight reel KO of Fernando Angulo was damn good even though Angulo is a little shopworn at this point, but beating two okay guys doesn't mean he'll set the world on fire at LWW or WW. The guys he's beaten recently don't even come close to preparing him for a Matthysse or Provodnikov. Much less big punchers at Welterweight.

    Konstantin Ponomarev-Very skilled kid who's very feather fisted as much as I want to believe he can be a big star my heart tells me he's going to be steamrolled by a big puncher. His style is okay but a little repetitive but he may get a small following by girls for his boyish good looks.

    Dmitry Mikhaylenko- I like him quite a lot and he's vastly improved over the last year, he could become a player, but his style is so awkward it might scare off potential opponents not wanting to risk it. Mikhaylenko has improved his defense and could easily become a serious threat in the near future, but I'm not sure how marketable he is to the general public.

    Sammy Vasquez-The Who Can Mexican put on a great match this year against Wale Omotoso it was a real barn burner, both of them were stunning each left and right, and then later he put on a defensive clinic against Jose Lopez and stopped him for the first time in his career, Sammy is a very versatile fighter, one of the bright spots in the division.

    Jessie Vargas-A limited feather fisted fighter who struggled against Allahkverdiev, Omotoso, Lopez looked average against DeMarco, and lost IMO to Novikov, his big Welterweight debut he was thoroughly schooled by Bradley. He's not exciting and his matches are instantly forgettable, no one cares about Jessie Vargas.

    Danny Garcia-Cherry Garcia himself has made his way to Welterweight with a bang with a BS stoppage of Malignaggi in a completely underwhelming performance, he already should have lost to Herrera and Peterson struggled with a shot Judah and lucked out Matthysse had one eye. His move to WW will be the beginning of his end, his punch resistance looked shaky against Peterson and his power has obviously been vastly overrated, he won't make it far.

    Shawn Porter-I'm a big fan of Shawn's I enjoy watching his matches, that being said Brook schooled him and Diaz made him look very average, his win over Paulie was a result of Paulie's awkward stance playing right into his hands, and the win over Devon is good, but Devon isn't that great, even though that's his nickname. Shawn will certainly make for some entertaining matches but he's limited.

    Adrien Broner-The Problem is a very simple riddle to solve since he's already lost to Maidana and Porter....and Quintero...and De Leon...and Malignaggi...and almost to Taylor. He's a buffoon with too many flaws to count and lacks the motivation and dedication to even attempt to solve the many Problems the Problem possesses. Put a fork in him...he's done.

    Chris Algieri-I'm a big fan and supporter of Algieri's and think he has the potential to upset many apple carts, however I don't see him being able to beat a Brook very easily and would probably struggle with quite a few of the bigger punchers in the division, but his fan friendly new style will make for some fun matches.

    Jose Benavidez Jr.-Really talented but should already have one loss by schooling from the Maestro Herrera and didn't look great against Jorge Paez Jr., I was hoping for the best with Jose but he's starting to feel like a hypejob.

    Rances Barthelemy-Imagine Erislandy Lara meets Guillermo Rigondeaux only far more dull that's Rancid for you in a nutshell, not fan friendly in the least.

    Viktor Postol-The Light Welterweight version of Wladimir Klitschko only not as exciting and no power, and he most likely won't get past Matthysse. Not one to get our hopes up about, that being said he's an incredibly skilled jabbing machine.

    Eduard Troyanovsky-He's very heavy handed and is capable of delivering a few highlight reel KO's but his lack of skill will be his downfall the moment he gets in the ring with someone who can take is power, he's far from hard to outbox.



    Now onto the Fading Current Stars.

    Tim Bradley-His chin and his skills seem to erode a little more with every passing match, his days are numbered as a top fighter.

    Juan Manuel Marquez-He's as close to retired as you can get, and he may want to consider it before making a return to the ring or he may end up like Sergio Martinez.

    Brandon Rios-Could be in a few more good wars, but how much more damage can he take before its irreparable?

    Robert Guerrero-Huge fan of the Ghost but he ain't too hot lately especially get dropped by Aaron Martinez of all people and he's seemingly unwilling to go back to pure boxing and his blood and guts act is too dangerous at this weight class for him. So its almost over for him.

    Marcos Maidana-Does he even care anymore? Not sure. Even if he does he's very limited, great againt average gatekeepers not so great against top guys.

    Mike Alvarado-Its Over, he needs to retire and seek some help before he winds up yet another tragic story in the annals of boxing history.

    Diego Chaves-Hasn't had one really good win of real significance, perpetual gatekeeper status.

    Devon Alexander-Gatekeeper as well, may trouble a few propects here and there.

    Andre Berto-What's left of his career that's already in shambles as it is will be polished off by Mayweather.

    The Also Rans-Frankie Gavin, JoJo Dan, Kevin Bizier, Ray Robinson, Roberto Garcia, Luis Carlos Abregu, Victor Ortiz, Josesito Lopez, Luis Collazo are all on the verge of being completely irrelevant.


    See the hottest Division in the sport isn't looking too hot anymore, sure there'll be some decent exciting matchups here and there but there's not a hell of a lot to get excited about. Maybe I'm being a little too grim but I don't think so.



    This content is protected
     
  2. ellerbe

    ellerbe Loyal Member Full Member

    38,718
    15,253
    Jul 25, 2014
    Crawford
    Brook
    Thurman
    Spence(though he's unproven)
    Khan(if his chin can hold up, he needs to fight a puncher and if he survives he's definitely a threat)

    All in their mid 20's-30's are some great talent. Also i thought you had Garcia beating Peterson. I remember I said I picked Garcia but I had Peterson winning and you said the opposite.
     
  3. CST80

    CST80 De Omnibus Dubitandum Staff Member

    238,344
    229,037
    Nov 23, 2013
    I scored it 7-5 Garcia but it could have been a draw, but most on here thought Peterson won. So I was in the minority of people who thought Danny won, regardless he didn't look impressive at all and struggle throughout the match.
     
  4. ellerbe

    ellerbe Loyal Member Full Member

    38,718
    15,253
    Jul 25, 2014
    What Weight classes from 122-hw do you see being the strongest era once floyd/pac retire, and make a small list of the young guys in each of these divisions. Don't list guys like Kovalev/GGG/Stevenson etc because they're all old, and by the time Pac retires I think they wont be as close to being as effective.
     
  5. ellerbe

    ellerbe Loyal Member Full Member

    38,718
    15,253
    Jul 25, 2014
    A draw or 7-5 for Garcia isn't a non-impressive win at all. Peterson is a good opponent, I was stressing this before the fight so many times, but everyone was like Garcia will walk through him blah blah blah. I had Peterson winning pretty wide to be honest, but if you scored it for Garcia you should give him credit. And I rewatched the fight with Paulie and he was dominating every round, and I dont think the stoppage was bs, all Paulie could do is take a longer beating. Garcia is definitely not half as bad as people make him out to be since he beat half of this forum's hero in matthyse.
     
  6. CST80

    CST80 De Omnibus Dubitandum Staff Member

    238,344
    229,037
    Nov 23, 2013
    I'll do that tomorrow I'm too tired after writing that, but I think Featherweight, Middleweight, Heavyweight, Cruiserweight, Flyweight and Light Heavyweight are all looking more promising than Welter in the near future.
     
  7. CST80

    CST80 De Omnibus Dubitandum Staff Member

    238,344
    229,037
    Nov 23, 2013
    What we think of Lamont is irrelevant, most don't think very highly of him, just because you and I rate him doesn't mean the majority of fans do, they look at him as a PED cheat who got KO'd in 3 by Matthysse.
     
  8. ellerbe

    ellerbe Loyal Member Full Member

    38,718
    15,253
    Jul 25, 2014
    I dont see most of these even competing especially MW, since that weight class is trash, and GGG is getting old, but I can see LHW and FW but like I said you can't name guys like Stevenson/Kovalev, hell even Beterbiev is older than any of the WW's you named.

    I dont follow Cruiser enough to comment, but disagree heavily on MW, HW, we'll see tomorrow if you change my mind. You'll probably make several threads, but i think it'd be easier all in one :good.
     
  9. ellerbe

    ellerbe Loyal Member Full Member

    38,718
    15,253
    Jul 25, 2014
    Wasn't it proven that Peterson took the pellets for health reasons? He outboxed Khan, and drew with Ortiz, when you say majoirty dont think hihgly of him it's probably mostly haters of black fighters, or haters of danny. Sure he got ko'd by Matthyse in 3, but Pac got put to sleep in 6 against Marquez does that mean everything he did before means nothing?
     
  10. CST80

    CST80 De Omnibus Dubitandum Staff Member

    238,344
    229,037
    Nov 23, 2013
    You're right I'm planning this as a series.:lol::nut
     
  11. ellerbe

    ellerbe Loyal Member Full Member

    38,718
    15,253
    Jul 25, 2014
    :finger
     
  12. CST80

    CST80 De Omnibus Dubitandum Staff Member

    238,344
    229,037
    Nov 23, 2013
    Right back at ya.:nutcase
     
  13. ellerbe

    ellerbe Loyal Member Full Member

    38,718
    15,253
    Jul 25, 2014
    go to sleep man its 7pm here so it has to be like 5-7 am over there.
     
  14. Capt

    Capt Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,906
    45
    Jul 12, 2013
    Indeed, CST80 lives here. Just look at how much he posts and the detail he uses.
     
  15. junkhead

    junkhead My dogs watch me post Full Member

    2,913
    2,103
    Mar 26, 2015
    I've got a feeling it's gonna be a while until we see/can appreciate another fighter who can manage a career as great as Pacquiao and Mayweather's. Enjoy 'em while they last fellas, no matter the hate between both fans, they've both been amazing athletes and stand so far above the current crop, prime for prime.