The Ring 100 = pile of pish

its opinion not fact u can nitpick any list

 

I like how that Salgado bloke who lands one punch on Linares and jumps from nowhere to top 30

 

yea that was strange also martinez was way down

 

Sorry my mistake I didnt know Valero had left Golden Boy you are right.

 

jesus christ hes above Tomasz Adamek atschatschatschatsch

 

adamek at 30 is stupid, given the fights he's been in & the fact he's won a ring belt. he should be in the top 15.

and darchinyan, who has blown out a "pound for pounder" in mijares, holds titles at 2 weights, stopped numerous world class fighters (pacheco, arce, kirilov) down in the 60s: insane.

and haye was far too low, given he beat an undispued (pretty much) champ in mormeck, destroyed his unification opponent (macca), won a heavyweight belt (valuev), and was beating - and knocking out - world class comp (frago, gurov) for the bloody EUROPEAN title at cruiserweight. also, the fact that he won his 2 belts in france and germany as well...yank writer wouldn't give a damn about that, would he?

 

just echo my comment again Ring aren't what they we're their top 100 list used to be fairly accurate but this years was terrible their standards are going down all the time their ratings in general are just horrible.

And here is the top 25 (horrible just horrible)
1. MANNY PACQUIAO
2. FLOYD MAYWEATHER
3. SHANE MOSLEY
4. BERNARD HOPKINS
5. JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
6. NONITO DONAIRE
7. MIGUEL COTTO
8. CELESTINO CABALLERO
9. CHAD DAWSON
10. PAUL WILLIAMS
11. ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
12. RAFAEL MARQUEZ
13. HOZUMI HASEGAWA
14. ARTHUR ABRAHAM
15. SERGIO MARTINEZ
16. KELLY PAVLIK
17. IVAN CALDERON
18. CHRIS JOHN
19. WLADIMIR KLITSCHKO
20. FERNANDO MONTIEL
21. VITALI KLITSCHKO
22. ANTONIO MARGARITO
23. TIMOTHY BRADLEY
24. JOSHUA CLOTTEY
25. MIKKEL KESSLER

Oh yeah and if you have time check out their top prospects list weight by weight this is also terrible.

http://www.ringtv.com/blog/1479/top_prospects_to_watch_in_2010/
http://www.ringtv.com/blog/1481/top_prospects_to_watch_in_2010__part_ii/

 

Why is Kessler 24 places ahead of Ward??

 

how the **** is chad dawson in the top 10?

he hasnt done **** scince his win over adamek....

he beat 2 grandfathers, TWICE (as if the first fights werent convincing enough /face palm) and then he fought 2 tomato cans....

 

Donaire shouldn't be anywhere near the top 10.

 

I posted this in another thread after reading that shitty list in the mag

'Just reading this Top 100 horse****, who writes this crap, The Ring need to get off Bernard Hopkins's nuts, the guy fights once every 18 months and is rated No4 same as last year without even having a fight in the 12 months from the last list, Arthur Abraham at 13 based on wins over Raul Marquez, Lajuan Simon and Mahir Oral!?!?! Glen Johnson jumping up 36 to 18 based on wins over Aaron Norwood and Daniel Judah. Juan Carlos Salgado crashing the rankings at 28!!?!! based on one win over Jorge Linares and our own Carl Froch entering the rankings at 59!! even though he's beaten Pascal, Taylor and Dirrell???

What a pile of ****'

 

This list different from the mag 100 then?