The Ring: "Mayweather Doesn't Crack The Top 25 Greatest Ever"

p4p rankings are **** to begin with.

 

Top 50, no higher than that in my opinion.

 

That would seem about right, i think i would have PBF sneaking into my top 25 if i ever get round to doing one but would not argue with anyone that didn't have him there

 

As long as he is above Oscar, it's all good!:good

 

Sounds decent at Top 50 but sad at the same time. With the quality of opposition at the moment I think he could become top 25. WW is a great division.

 

Agreed, an argument could be made against it as well.

 

No Lennox Lewis in top 50?

 

That list is ****ing horrible and has been discussed here.

 

That list still makes me nauseous. Whoever did that list, seriously, does not **** about boxing. That is an armchair, youtube watching highlight media geek.

 

I think Floyd has ATG talent but lacks an ATG resume. I think ESPN has it right. If he grew some balls and attempted to unify the ww division like the real ATG would have done, he would elevate his status, but I think #48 is right where he belongs. The nuthuggers just can't grasp that its not all about talent alone.

 

That list was actually better than what I would've expected from ESPN.

 

Did Dan Rafael do the list?Couldn't have,right?

 

He has the tools, but is too stingy with his talent. Roy Jones as well. They both could have been among the top 5 for sure, but avoided too many guys and potentially interesting fights. Now we'll never know.

 

30-50 would be fair. Any higher is absurd to be honest.

I'm thinking higher end of that range too.