The Ring rate Broner #5 P4P

No, its HOW YOU DO IT AND WHO YOU DO IT TO.

Beating up DeMarco and being placed at top 5 is flat out disgusting and anyone that agrees with it is a straight up dumb ****ing idiot.

How the **** did Guerrero got to the top 10? By beating ****in Berto??? Why didnt Ortiz get in when he beat an undefeated berto??

The fact that these 2 are in is a ****ing joke and the fact that Mares got thrown out and that they havent even bothered to place Viloria is ****ing outrageous.

**** the Ring Magazine and **** all those cocksuckers who gave the green light to make this ****ing joke of a list.

 

Time will tell and I hope everyone that is up in arms will remember that questioned his ranking.

 

Yes, time will tell. But at the moment, time has already told and Broner isn't top ten pound for pound, let alone #5!

 

Heres one where do people think Broner will be in ranking wise next year this time?

 

Not a big deal, P4P is all subjective. If you want to talk in terms of skill level, it's not inconceivable to have Broner or even Rigondeaux in the top 10. If they made a mistake, time will tell and he will be swiftly removed from p4p when that time comes. However, I have a feeling that he will be among the top 10 for many years to come.

 

I saw this yesterday and was gonna say something.

But yeah its ridiculous rating him that high, he is American so that automatically gets him rated way above what he should and I have always thought that the lighterweight fighters always get rated above they're bigger counterparts.

They get too much rating points for jumping up a few divisions that are only what 3-4lbs difference most of the time

 

I'm a big Broner fan but top 5 P4P is ridiculous, simply hasn't done enough yet. With that said he does have top 5 P4P talent.

 

I can't actually see how anyone can justify Broner making the top 10 right now

 

This content is protected

 

dbl

 

i lve broner but this **** is crazy

 

Why is it crazy I think its a good debate dude is a step above and time will tell.

 

By your rationale David Price should be in the top five. Where is Price on the list? WHERE IS HE?

 

so this is now the chuck giampa list? wtf hahaha giampa is the god of rankings all of a sudden. what were they thinking with that decision! I don't get how they just rearranged everything from the week before and threw in Guererro and Broner when the dudes they had in above them didn't lose. I think Gamboa was in there wasn't he? Was Mares at 10 after beating Moreno who was at 9? I don't remember. Anyone got the p4p listing for just before this change out of curiosity?

I still find it hilarious that Broners debutin at #5 though hahaha has this ever happened? a sudden entrance to top 5? madness but funny

 

This fella didn't do half as much as Donaire and Bradley and they shoot him into top5.
Donaire beat Darchinyan, Montiel and Nishioka, Bradley beat Peterson, Pacquiao, Alexander.
Who did Broner beat ? DeMarco... and that's about it. Big difference in achievements.